When Exactly Did Kids Asking for Stuff Become "Not Rude"?

Updated on December 05, 2013
A.J. asks from Norristown, PA
21 answers

I've noticed in kids my kid's ages, 4,5 and 7, (including my kids sometimes but I never let is slide) that it has become not uncommon for kids to approach adults in any setting, often interrupting, and ask for whatever they want. Some recent examples: We were at a party where there were some kids but mainly adults. Various kids ran up to the hostess of the party all night-often because they were getting bored- and directly asked for more and more cake, snacks, etc. The parents stood complacently by while the busy hostess scrambled to do their children's bidding. One kid even complained about his plate once the hostess brought it. I have also hosted a friend of my kids who continually approaches me to beg for stuff. Food, drinks, toys, things she sees out of reach she wants to play with, etc. When I say no, she pouts or stomps, and if I do get her something at an appropriate time IF she asked nicely, she'll sometimes say "she doesn't like it" or whatever. Her mom may or may not step in and correct her. She doesn't correct her for asking for stuff, she'll just sometimes say no to the thing she's asking for. She seems to see no problem with the child running up, interrupting and constantly wanting stuff. I've seen it many other places too. Some kids at a self-serve yogurt place the other night kept running up to the counter and begging the workers for more toppings in their bowls (not how it worked, you had to weigh them and pay, not just "get more") and the parents didn't say anything except, "No, sweetie, we've had enough sugar for now." Not, "Sit, down, it's not OK to do that." For instance one worker had his back to the kids wiping down a counter and a kid who looked about 8 was saying, "Hey! Hey, You! I want more sprinkles!" in a totally bossy tone.

Are you effing kildding me?

Who remembers the "Don't ask for stuff when you are a guest" days? Is having kids ask adults other than their parents for stuff OK with most people? OF COURSE if a child is genuinely thirsty or needs the restroom etc they should be able to speak up politely, but begging for snacks and even toys relentlessly from any old adult they see? Really? Why is this not considered rude anymore? I've had strange kids approach us at parks and ask for some of our snacks...In theory I don't mind sharing, and sometimes I offer, but I can't imagine telling my kids it's OK to go up and ask people for their stuff.

Personally my kids are told not to ask hosts for things unless it's an emergency, they should come to me instead and they must ask politely. When I have caught them approaching hosts and asking for ...a dessert they see laying out on the counter or whatever, I remind them it's not polite to ask, they need to wait for it to be offered. Does that host probably think I'm out of my mind in modern times?

Around friends and family we are very close to, my kids are allowed to ask politely for things, but not just at any old place. Is this archaic?

Any thoughts?

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

So What Happened?

Lovemy3kids, Like any other type of behavior, I know not ALL kids act like this, I'm only noticing the ones that do. And I was pointing out mine need reminding too, they're not perfect. But when a parent is standing there grinning at a party while their child repeatedly continues to ask a host for more and more treats and says nothing when the child reacts ungratefully, it's a fair bet they DON'T always admonish in the car or in private or the child wouldn't be acting that way. The situations I am mentioning are ones where you can tell the parents don't see anything wrong with the behavior. We all know how hard it is to discipline kids, and that even the best kids will have bad days, and we all also know what it looks like when people aren't disciplining at all and have opted to ignore instead. Some parents feel kids should be allowed to ask just like adults and that it would be beating their self esteem down to remind them otherwise in front of others, so that's why the kids do it.

Riley, I've missed you! But I beg to differ a bit. I've also traveled and adjusted, but these particular kids where we live now are not diverse and were born in the same "white middle class American region" their parents and grandparents were, which is very similar to where I was raised, and it would not have been considered OK 30 years ago to act like that.

Featured Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.R.

answers from Washington DC on

My mother always taught me not to ask for food etc at other people's houses and I never did. If they offered it, it was okay.

I recently did a post about how my neighbor's kids come over and raid the pantry, fridge, etc. without asking. I was appalled! I finally had to tell them that I don't buy a lot of snack food since I only have one kid and what I have I need for her lunch,

People do not teach their kids basic manners anymore. I'm older (50's) and I wish we could get some of that old social etiquette back!

7 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

R.M.

answers from San Francisco on

I don't know when this kind of rudeness became "normal," probably somewhere around the time when trashy talk shows and then vulgar reality shows became commonplace on tv.

It might be more common, but it's still rude.

7 moms found this helpful

More Answers

F.W.

answers from Danville on

This reminded me of when my first two kiddos were young, and I was pregnant with # 3. We were hosting a bar b que, and both sets of grands and other family members were there. My eldest son came running in, and began to interrupt. In my effort to demonstrate my 'superior' parenting, I mildly said, "Ryan, we are talking right now, you need to wait your turn" and turned back to the adult conversation. Then I turned to ryan to let him know it was his turn, and he said, "The grill is on fire!"

And it was!! lol

Thanks for the memory!

16 moms found this helpful

S.G.

answers from Grand Forks on

My kids are not allowed to ask for things other than what they need (water, the restroom or to use the phone) when they are at a party or at a friends house. I am surprised by how many of their friends come over and ask for snacks and treats, or bug me to buy them stuff when I take them on an outing. Jeez, I never buy my kids stuff on outings, why would I buy stuff for their friends! I figure that they must just be used to being given everything they ask for.

I do encourage my kids to speak up and be more assertive (although polite) when in a store, fast food restaurant, deli counter etc. I have noticed that employees tend to ignore kids when they stand patiently at the counter waiting for service, and unless the kid speaks up the server will continue to serve the adults, even if it is the childs turn.

9 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

H.W.

answers from Portland on

No, not archaic at all. We are the same way; even during Thanksgiving (which his godparents hosted) we made it clear that "this is the same as going to visit the Queen-- best manners, don't touch anything that isn't yours, and ask us if you need anything because Auntie and Uncle will be busy." I try to remind my son of expectations in advance.

I'm always rather surprised at the kids who come over and just demand to turn the tv on or to have some food. I let them know "oh, we don't watch tv during playtimes, because you are here to play".... and when the snacktime will be, if any. I always ask the parents when they drop off when the last time was that their kid ate and gauge snacktime from there... so the kid can have a cup of water if they are thirsty, snacktime is at such and such time. An authoritative manner helps!

(Can I also add that for the kids whose parents sort of cater to their whims... this is where we likely see more of this behavior. If they are used to mom and dad dropping everything to get something for Little Precious, they are more likely to expect it from other adults as well. They haven't been taught better.) ETA: The idea that we will damage our child's self-esteem by providing a quiet, mild correction in the moment is strange to me. All we have to do is lower our voices, bend down and say quietly "remember, you are to come and check with me if you need something, so let try that again" does not need to be traumatic to either parent or child. The reason we teach our son to ask us is social graciousness-- we are not putting another adult in the position of possibly having to deny our kid. My son *would* ask for food from another adult-- even if he'd just eaten-- if he had been taught that this was okay. Parents know best what the child needs, which is usually why we want our kids to defer to us-- and why most good hosts would double-check with parents anyway if approached directly.

9 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

C.B.

answers from Chicago on

This kind of question irks me... you're making everyone else's child seem like a monster but saying that you have taught your children right from wrong and never let it slide. I've taught my children what is appropriate and what's not and yes... they often still ask for things they know they shouldn't and say and do things that I don't consider appropriate. Do I always point it out to them in public in front of others... no. I don't want to beat their self esteem down into the ditch. Will I talk with them about it later privately... absolutely. It sounds like you've been having a bad week and we've all been there but again it irks me when people make assumptions about others parenting and put themselves on a pedestal. You don't know anything about these parents or children or what may have just been said or what will be said privately when they leave the place you encountered them. No I don't think it's ok to whine and beg for things but is it ok for children to ask for something they want? I think so. If you want something, I'm sure you would ask. Why can't children do the same? It's the adults job to say no if it's an inappropriate request.

9 moms found this helpful

L.A.

answers from Austin on

I agree with you. Thank goodness we rarely had this happen to us. Our daughter knew we did not act like this.

We were laughing yesterday about how our rule at the grocery store was " We do not buy snacks at the store", we can take out own snacks..

And yet, I see the parents letting their children stick their hands in the samples. (you are supposed to sue the tongs, the spoon or the paper placed out. ) Or at Costco, letting their children go back over and over for samples..

But the worse is at birthday parties when children say they want the corner piece of cake, or the piece with the rose on it etc.. In Kindergarten the teachers have to actually teach the children, "you get what you get.."
in these situations. Because the parents have not taught their children to be polite. And yes, if you are at home with your family and use your manners, you may request, but we do not demand.

8 moms found this helpful

S.T.

answers from Washington DC on

i'm archaic like you, hon. i don't see anything wrong with kids WANTING stuff, and wouldn't necessarily squelch them asking when they do. but i too find the demanding, bossy, rude tones that are so prevalent today to be incredibly obnoxious.
kids can be taught that 'expressing themselves' can and should be incorporated into 'courtesy.'
khairete
S.

7 moms found this helpful

C.V.

answers from Columbia on

I do agree that there's quite a lot of rudeness. But I agree with Riley....rude is subjective-ish.

On the other side of the coin, it drives me up the wall to see adults who fawn over children, doing things for them that the kids should be doing for themselves (getting a drink, throwing away something, preparing a dinner plate at the buffet). Kids aren't helpless....stop acting like the are, folks!

ETA: Ronda, why on earth would it bother you that a child is helping himself to the snacks while she sits and watches? Aren't they there for everyone? Is she supposed to get up and serve him?

6 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.B.

answers from Spartanburg on

I agree with you. The problem is that parents are too afraid of "offending" their child's sweet sensibilities and hurting their self-esteem to do what they need to do - be parents! When I was a little girl, going to someone's house meant being on my best behavior and being seen and not heard. Asking for more food or toys or ANYTHING would have been the height of rudeness and I feel the same way today.
I feel that we are starting to instill this same respectful mentality in our toddler. He knows that if he's out of line, there are consequences and we enforce them every single time.
There is no longer a line between a child and a grown up and there should be. Children should be respectful of all adults, all the time, PERIOD. (This, of course barring something out of the ordinary or extremely unlikely - a kidnapper, etc.) We've lost old fashioned respect in our society and rude, brash, and obnoxious children are the direct result.

6 moms found this helpful

T.S.

answers from San Francisco on

I guess I'm lucky, I rarely see this kind of behavior.
Sure it sometimes happens in a public place (there are jerks of ALL ages, right?) but the instances are so few and far between that it doesn't even phase me.
Maybe it depends on where you live.

6 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.C.

answers from Anchorage on

I think you talk about some different kinds of situations, and in some of them I agree with you, in others I do not. Is it rude to ask a sales person for more for free? Or to ask a stranger at the park for their food? Yes, of course it is, and I hope the parents are being informed about such behavior so it can be corrected. BUT, asking the host at a party, or someones parent that you know and are spending time with, for something is not out of line at all. IF they are interrupting then I would politely point that out to them and tell them they must wait until I am done talking and then ask their question, but I would not consider it rude that they asked. If they do not ask then how will they know if they can have it or not? If I say no and they whine then I would hope the parent would correct the situation, but if not, as host, I would have no issue doing so myself.

4 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

G.L.

answers from Salt Lake City on

It's not archaic in my house. I've taught my children that when they are guests, they are allowed to ask for water and where the rest room is. And unless it is a bathroom emergency, they are not to interrupt to ask even those things.

4 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.S.

answers from Austin on

I hear you. You know what is worse? When they just starting getting their own food/drink without even asking and the parent just sits back because why – they are family? Friends? I’m sorry but I was taught you ask nicely (and don’t interrupt) even if you are at another family members house or friends house. Oh and it was also instilled in me to ask if the hostess needed help. I swear it’s become a me, me, me world.

Ha that reminds me of another pet peeve – what happened to “if you are at someone else’s house, you are on your best behavior and you follow their rules" or "you don't rummage through someone else's things." I say the last because we were at a party where the kids where going into other rooms and messing with the hosts' personal belongings. The parents were not even paying attention.

4 moms found this helpful

M.D.

answers from Washington DC on

I also rarely see this. I have taught my kids the right manners, but sometimes they do what they want anyways, they are kids. We are adults and also mess up.

If you are seeing this a lot - maybe it's time to change the kind of parents you hang around with. The kids mostly have learned behaviors.

3 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

B..

answers from Dallas on

I have seen it, too. I try to model good behavior in Sunday School. We occasionally get to pick out something from the "treasure chest", a collection of pencils, balloons and shtuff. There are still kids who come into class asking if they can get something today. I gently let them know, it's not polite to ask.

3 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

R.J.

answers from Seattle on

It's a cultural thing, not a generational thing.

Meaning,,, I grew up travelling.

In some places we lived, the POLITE thing is for a child to ask directly.
In other places we lived the POLITE thing is for a child to ask through an intermediary. (Your standard).
In others, the POLITE thing is for a child to not ask, but to take care of themselves.
In others, the POLITE thing is for children to not ask at all (seen but not heard)

4 totally different Versions of polite =
75% chance of being seen as rude

Now...When I was a child (insert 'the tone' ;) most people were pretty ethnocentric/geographically stable. What was polite was polite for the whole REGION. Everyone had basically the same standards. So it was pretty easy to evaluate. We'd move into a new town/state/country... And
1) Found out what was polite for the region (in this and MANY other matters)
2) Always follow the lead of the hostess (if the hostess is nekkid, ya strip down.)

THESE DAYS... It's a lot more difficult.
People travel a lot more (school, work, etc.)
People adopt different standards (people are more globally connected via media/Internet).

Which means that while I'll still generally pay attention to regional norms, ITs reeeeeeeeally common for a single gathering to have people with completely differing norms. Which makes following the Hostess's lead even more important.

3 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.S.

answers from Pittsburgh on

Amen sister! I think the "art of manners" is being lost. I'm sure I'm guilty of not correctly teaching my children, or not correctly reacting when they don't have manners, as either we get lazy or just "flow with norm". It bothers me when friends' children ask me for things, as you've described.

Someday I'd like to sign my girls up for a manners course (probably for me too!).

3 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

C.H.

answers from Chicago on

Sometimes you model good manners explain and re-explain the reasons to your child and they still do what they want.

1 mom found this helpful

R.X.

answers from Houston on

Love my 3 kids (and her 8 flower bearers) I don't read her saying that her kids are perfect.

I hosted a Clothing Swap Party last Friday. One lady brought her son. She always does as she is a single working gal and wants time with him. We don't mind that. What we do mind is that he helps himself over and over to snacks and she sits and watches.

So, I agree. I guess those who disagree with you may be the parents of kids of whom you are referring...

"A hit dog will holler".

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

G.♣.

answers from Springfield on

I don't think it's necessarily bad manners for a child to ask an adult for something. I can remember being at a gathering at someone's house and my parents encouraging me to ask the host for something, rather than asking them. I was very timid and nervous to talk to the adults, and they wanted me to push myself to make the request.

Now, I think there are times when it isn't a simple request and does border on being rude. There's a difference between asking for something to drink and requesting a meal. But I don't think it's rude for children to ask (nicely) the host for something.

I understand "they need to wait to be offered" to an extent. I don't think being polite is archaic, exactly. But I think our society is a bit more relaxed than your examples suggest.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions