Hi F.,
Your parenting for your two other children sounds like it is working. However, each child is different and it sounds like your 5 yr. old son needs a different parenting style. You know... what works for one doesn't necessarily mean it works for another. When times are tough with him, bite your tongue.... and don't say... "Why can't you just listen to me like your sister and brother do?" Not saying you do, but if you do, this will make him respond worse and eventually learn to resent his siblings.
He sounds like he needs things broken down into STEPS for him to succeed. It sounds overwhelming in his eyes and he probably doesn't even know where to begin. It could be ADD or it could be that as he is getting older, and more is being required of him to do things independently and he is in need of sorting through things. I was an elementary teacher before having my own kids, and I'll tell you that making a LIST for some of the kids help them succeed TREMENDOUSLY.
I think he needs a MORNING CHECK OFF LIST to remind him to stay focused. My kids don't have ADD and it still helped them when I did this for them in kindergarten through second grade. They outgrew their need for their own list and now as 4th graders, they just do what they know they need to do before school. You can have your son check off or put a happy face after he does the task..... ie...
_____ 7:30-7:45 Eat Breakfast
_____ 7:45- 8:00 Bathroom Time (specifcally state what needs to be done)
(Use toliet, wash hands, brush hair, and brush teeth)
______ 8:00 Get school clothes on
______ Now I can relax and READ until Mom is ready to leave. (Have special fun type magazines that can only be used during this time such as Ranger Rick.)
Make sure to have him agree on the clothing choice THE NIGHT BEFORE. Have all papers signed, homework done, etc... by the time homework is done that very same evening. Backback, jacket, projects, gym shoes, etc... that he needs should be all ready to go the night before. A section for all of these belongings would be nice. Google organized mudrooms or such.... on this to see what I am talking about.( each child has his own coat hook, shelf, etc..)
DO NOT show a lot of angry emotions when he doesn't do what you've asked him to do and don't respond out of anger. (Not saying you do...) SHOW a LOT of praise when he follows through with tasks and monitor him throughtout the morning. Yes... it will be work on your part, but it will be well worth it and it will be pay off! ie... "Oh... Jake, I see you already have two smiley faces drawn by your morning to do list. THAT is so AWESOME. Okay... I am going back to making lunches now. I can't wait to see some more smiley faces on your list.
I used a site called dltk.com years ago to make my free printable list that you can customize. (Of course there are several websites as well as just making your own with paper and crayons.) Reward him by some time alone with him... mommy and son time to ride a bike, walk to an ice cream store and chat just the two of you, etc.... Of course your other kids will need their own time too with you.
From my experience as a teacher, so much of what results in the outcome of a child, is how the adult reacts to the response. If you ask him Why questions a lot when he misbehaves, try to do less of this. Why questions are often abstract to young kids. ie... Why aren't you ready, yet?, Why are you just playing with your toys. It's so late. Why do you still have on your pajamas?
Instead try.... "Jake, let's see how quickly you can go change into your clothes. I bet you can do it in less than 2 minutes." He comes down in 2 minutes all dressed, say... "Wow, you can be so responsible. I am proud of you for doing what needs to be done. You'll be able to make it to school on time today. Great job at listening, honey!"
Try not crying over spilt milk while driving to work.When I was a teacher, I used to use my commuting time to be a reflective learner....Okay, so my approach didn't not work with Katie, what can I DO DIFFERENTLY to try to get her to respond better next time?
I am all "ears" if you need anymore help, just pm me.
All my best,
J.