Sister-in-law Troubles - Flagler Beach,FL

Updated on March 30, 2012
V.M. asks from Norwood, PA
7 answers

Thanks for the help!

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

More Answers

T.K.

answers from Dallas on

I'm spiteful. I would probably lead her in the wrong direction and pull a fake out. Tell her I'm putting the kids in figure skating lessons but actually tae kwon do. I'd tell her your new hobby is blown glass or some ridiculous thing she has to invest money into and the next time she asks about it, just laugh at her. Tell her you have started going to therapy and it is really helping you deal with your issues - that way she will get her butt in therapy!

I think you're husband has the right idea. She must be so impressed, in awe, and jealous of you that she wants to be you. Or it could be that your brother puts you on a pedestal to her and she wants him to worship her the way he does you. Either way, I'd luagh it off. Turn it into a drinking game. Every time she imitates you take a shot!

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.W.

answers from Seattle on

OK. You got pregnant, and suddenly your sis rushes out and tries to get preggers? Do you mean she went off birth control? Or suddenly started having sex when she wasn't? This sounds a tad far-fetched to me.

Your sil was probably thinking about or considering a number of the things you mentioned before you did it. (Homeschooling seems to be a big trend these days.) Maybe seeing you do it pushed her over the edge to try it, maybe not. Why do you care? How does it affect you? Really. How does it affect you? It shouldn't. Does her homeschooling take away from yours? Does she live in a fashion vacuum only influenced by you? Should she not try to attend family events when a family member comes into town?

I don't get it. Stop worrying about what she's doing. Period. End of story.

And, if you really do manage to come up with something completely original and not influenced by anything else, hide it from your SIL. Until then, recognize that we are all influenced by external ideas.

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.R.

answers from Washington DC on

I can sure see how this would wear you down after years of feeling copied. But I also find your sister-in-law frankly sad and pitiful, more to be pitied than disliked.

She must be either so enamored of you and what she sees as your great ideas that she does not even try to come up with ideas and activities of her own; or she is so tragically blank when it comes to having her own thoughts and feelings that she just copies someone else. I wonder if her family history would show that even as a kid and teenager, she copied other kids? I have a feeling it would. She sounds insecure and she may feel that she's just a cipher, a kind of paper doll person who has nothing of her own going on, so she sticks like a barnacle to whatever is suggested to her -- and yes, I know you're not "making suggestions" but are just conveying information; however, somewhere in the depths of her mind she thinks, "What a good idea. I'll do that too."

Can you possibly, after all these years, try to see her as pathetic and sad, as someone who may have a fundamental personality problem, as someone who may be deeply insecure and not really know herself or own mind? If you can, that may help you to brush off her copying. She may indeed see it as her flattering you, even if you don't. Show your own confidence in what you do and say by ignoring the copying and saying, "Oh, poor Sally, if she's happy doing what I do, good for her because she doesn't seem to be able to come up with things on her own and that's just sad." Say this to yourself - not her, because she won't see it.

It does sound like there are other, deeper issues here between you and your brother, too -- you say he, not just she, must be the center of attention, and seem to resent the idea that both are "at every event" if a relative visits (you say you are OK with those things -- but why bring them up if you're really OK with them at the deepest level?). Your issues with her may be tangled up iin a lifetime of issues with your brother.

I guess the key here is this: Do you like them as people? Would you be interested to talk with them if they were not relatives? Do you share any interests or opinions or history with them that makes you enjoy their company? If not -- limit your contact with them and don't talk about your life and your activities when you do talk; talk about the weather, TV, their kids, whatever. If you DO actually like them on some level, then find activities to do with her--specific things to see and places to be, so that you are doing less chatting and more activity. But it sounds to me like this is a case of "they're family and not folks I would really have as friends otherwise." In that case, limit contact, arrange separate events with visiting family members ("Oh, our schedules just clash this time so we're seeing X on our own") or whatever.

But mostly she sounds pitiful.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

H.M.

answers from Dallas on

I am with Tracy!!!!!!!!!!! :) I would tell her you have decided that it is vain to have hair and you are going to save your head. Sorry I know I am not much help.

Good luck and God Bless!!!!

1 mom found this helpful

K.I.

answers from Los Angeles on

I can see where this would be kind of irritating, that is for sure...

But you say you want to get over it, correct? So, ask yourself: How does her copying you effect you? Does it interfere with your life in any way? If the answer is NO, then truly get over it. Just let it go.

Maybe stop sharing so much with her, especially your 'fun' things that are special to you that you know would hurt your feelings if you found out she was copying you about.

~To me, unless she is trying to take credit with family members or friends, over stuff that you came up with and that are meaningful to you, I would not be bothered by her imitating me.

Is there anyway that you have a chip on your shoulder about her and are suggesting she copies you on stuff when really she isn't? I mean the getting pregnant when you get pregnant is kind of far fetched, IMO. I mean she can NOT copy when you ovulate or when you have sex...somethings MotherNature or GOD have control over, not just you or her, ya know what I mean?

I am sure there are lots of other examples you could give but the ones you have suggested seem kinda petty on your end, just saying. I mean, I know lots of people who have enrolled their kids in piano lessons and that celebrate passover, does that mean they have copied you too?

So I say again, not to be snarky but to truly help you get over it, like you say you want to....just let it go and acknowledge the fact that she has the right to do with her life what she sees fit and so do you....and that is OK if you guys have overlapping hobbies or taste...

P.W.

answers from Dallas on

I don't find what you describe as flattering. I find it as annoying and it makes me think your SIL is not comfortable in her own skin.

I don't have a real answer for you. Just a thought. Maybe what your SIL really needs is a little attention from you. Maybe you could help her to find herself, so to speak. Encourage her to take up some new interests and help her to explore how to figure out what it is SHE likes.

I'd also keep a little bit of a distance. Try not to run in the same social groups, etc...

Good Luck!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

H.P.

answers from Houston on

I wish that I could have read your question. I have SIL issues, too, and I don't like to keep coming back here asking for perspective. Sometimes I like to let other people do the work by being the ones to tell their stories and ask the questions.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions