Sisters in Law Causing Trouble...

Updated on December 16, 2008
J.A. asks from Austin, TX
4 answers

So, here's my story: 2 of my brothers are not speaking because their wives got into it a few months ago. The funny thing is (not really), with the holidays, I know there is going to be a huge amount of tension in the air at Christmas. I don't think they are being fair to my nieces & nephews for keeping them apart because of their stupidity. They may not even show up for Christmas. Anybody ever dealt with this kind of situation? If you were me, would you say anything or just let it be?

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

More Answers

L.A.

answers from Austin on

Stay out of it! Just say that you are hoping to see everyone for the holidays.

State where and what time the family event will be held and then let them decide what they will do.

If they try to drag you into it, tell them they need to settle this among themselves. Treat them like you would 5 year olds. They can decide what is the bast way to handle this. Do not make a big deal. Their loss should should not affect the rest of you.

If they do not attend, still ask your nieces and nephews how their mothers are but do not show any negative feelings one way or the other. Do not allow others in attendance to make comments either. Make this a "drama free zone".

On a personal note I am going to post my version of my decision of no longer participating with my inlaws after almost 30 years of marriage.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

G.K.

answers from Austin on

The same situation has happened in our family on several occasions.
Take it from someone who knows.....It's not worth ruining your own holiday while trying to repair someone elses.
All you can to is to make sure is everyone is aware of the fact that there is going to be a gathering along with all of the details. We just started adding the statement "We would love to see you all and will miss you if you're unable to attend." And you know what? The kids will get together on their own eventually regardless of how infantile the parents act!
Happy Holidays.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.G.

answers from Austin on

I've got family that always seems to be getting into a tiff here and there and I'm always stuck in the middle of it like the mediator. Something about the holidays always seems to make it worse. Talk to the brothers and see if one of them is willing to extend the olive branch and make peace to the other. If someone does that than maybe there is time to find a way to be nice to each other. If neither is willing to stop being mad than there isn't much you can do but let it blow over. It does stink that the kids might not get to see each other and it's a shame that the parents can't see what it does to their kids to have feuds like this. Unfortunately adults can act worse than children sometimes.

Like I said, talk to each brother and find out if someone is willing to bend. Use the kids as a way to tug the heart strings. Remind them that it's the holidays and even if they have to just "act" nice doing it for the kids would be the right thing to do. But don't push too hard. If you were an outsider you could just say your thoughts and walk away but your in the family too and you don't want to get drawn into their fight. Make sure you stay neutral and let them know before you even start talking to them that that is where you are going to stay. And if it seems like what you're doing isn't going to work just let it go. Families fight. VERY loudly sometimes. Staying neutral will help everyone. If they ask your opinion give it if it's not going to make the situation worse. But don't be afraid to speak your mind about the holidays and the kids seeing each other. Thats an obvious reminder that both brothers seem to need. If they tell you point blank to stay out of it then do that.

Lastly, I would clear it with your hubby first before you talk to his brothers. Just let him know what you're doing so he doesn't get ambushed with phone calls later or something. He might have some insight on how to deal with each brother separately or he might just want to do the mediating himself.

If it all doesn't work out try to have a good holiday without them and know that you're doing the right thing by trying to help, even if that means staying neutral.

Good luck! Love to hear how all this turns out.
Jen
http://www.mommysjoy.com

OH, and one other helpful thought. When I'm playing mediator (it's my two sisters that get into it all the time) a lot of the time I will act like they are the first person I called. What I mean is, the person on the other end of the phone will want to tell you their story without thinking that you've already been tainted with the other's story. Sometimes it's just better to let them think they are getting the first word in. It doesn't always help in every situation but sometimes they just need someone to vent to and if you aren't "tainted" then they can feel like they are talking to a non-biased person.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.A.

answers from Austin on

let 'em sit this one out. I have the same issues with my mother and my mother in law. They both seem to get along with us but they are always at each others throats. Last Christmas I told them that I was not willing to invite drama into my home for Christmas, so we just did something else. They were both hurt that they didn't get to come so this year they have both been on their best behavior. You don't need to let the drama spill over to your Christmas. You have to do whats right for your family. Good Luck!

1 mom found this helpful
For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions