Problems with My Sister - Neptune,NJ

Updated on July 01, 2010
S.H. asks from Neptune, NJ
10 answers

This isn't a parenting question but I am hoping for some helpful advice. My older sister has been living with a guy for 6 years. In the beginning things were good with them but as time has gone on he has become more and more abusive to her. She has never told me that he hits her but he is always yelling and putting her down. He sold her car and takes her paychecks so she is completely dependant on him. (I begged her not to sell her car but she didn't listen) She is constantly calling me and complaining about how terrible he is and yet when I tell her to leave him she always says she has no where to go. Many times we've been talking and he will grab the phone and hang it up. He disappears for days on end leaving her stranded in the house then comes back with no explanation. She wants to come stay in my house but there is no room for her here unless I make my kids share a bedroom. I have a boy and a girl I don't think that is fair to do to them. My parents no longer speak to her because her last boyfriend cleaned out their bank accounts and my sister lied to the police and said they gave him the money. She is kind of a mess but she is also my sister. I've given her money in the past to get back on her feet after she broke up with a guy but my husband said no more after the last one. She wants to leave and has no way to do it. Do any of you know of a way to help without giving her money or letting her stay with me? She doesn't have any friends to stay with as she has burned all those bridges too. She claims she can't get into a shelter because she isn't physically abused. Is that true? She lives in Georgia so I can't really go help her out but I also don't want to completely bail on her. I know she does this with every guy she gets involved with but she's also my sister. Thanks for any help you can give.

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

So What Happened?

First thank you all for the advice. I think I probably knew this asking the question but sometimes it helps to hear other people agree with you. (I hope that makes sense) She is 38 years old, has no children and to my knowledge does not use drugs or drink. She had her own bank account but closed it when she "got engaged" to this guy and now just gives him her checks to put in his account. She isn't wearing a ring and they have made no plans that I know of to get married, thankfully. She sold her car and gave him the money 2 years ago because he was going to get her a better car but of course that never happened. Now if she needs to go somewhere he has to take her or she doesn't go. They live in a pretty rural area in Georgia and I live in NJ so driving her around is pretty impossible. One of the main reasons I don't want her to stay with us (aside from the fact that I think this guy may come looking for her) is she has made inappropriate advances toward my husband. He completely freaked out (I was in the hospital after just having had my son and she was in my bed when he got out of the shower) and threw her out. She claimed she was just "playing with him". Since then he does not want her staying with us and I can't say I blame him. I really think she has some mental problems but everyone else in the family just says she has to grow up. I don't want her to set a bad example for my children we pride ourselves on teaching our kids to be responsible and respectful and she would not respect those teachings. I guess there really isn't a way for me to help her because she does seem to enjoy the drama in her life it's just hard to not want to because even after all the mess she has created she is my sister and I do love her. Thank you all for the words of advice I think I will call some shelters just to get information and then then at least when she calls complaining I can give her the numbers and tell her if she really wants to change it she can. Thanks again as always for all the help!

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.S.

answers from Los Angeles on

I dont think shelter even needs to be considered here b/c she has a job! What do you mean he takes her paychecks? How? Can't she just get a live check from her work and not give it to him? Deposit it into another account that she opens up? Etc. I don't think the problem is so much that she has nowhere to go but that she doesn't WANT to go. That's a sad conclusion to come to but it sounds to me like she's just using that as an excuse to not leave. She works, she gets money. She could leave whenever she wanted. I doubt her boss is giving the check to her husband =P

And yes, I agree with others, don't give her money.

Sorry you're going through this but unforunately you can't make your sister make better choices..

10 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.F.

answers from Philadelphia on

You really want to help her? Stop giving her money. When she is ready to be done with him she will end it. For some reason your sister loves guys who are abusive and there isn't anything you can do to make her stop. I understand you feel bad for her but look at her track record. Stop letting her take advantage of you, you are enabling her and she knows you feel bad so she is using you.

She has ways to leave she just doesn't want to do it.

5 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

P.W.

answers from San Francisco on

No! Don't let her live with you or give her money!

She has paychecks, so obviously she has a job. She can move out and get roommates, if she can't afford to live on her own. What do you mean she has no way to leave? That's ridiculous. If you want to help her, look in the paper or internet for apartment rentals or roommate situations.

Or tell her to do it herself. She's a grown woman.

4 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

M.M.

answers from Detroit on

I think you need to encourage her to go to a shelter. It is very doubtful to me that they would turn someone away who is significantly emotionally abused. I would not give her money based on her history. This is a really difficult situation. The benefit of a shelter would be some counseling there, maybe it would help her not fall into the same pattern again. I believe they would also do job placement assistance. I would call some shelters in her area and see what they say. Good luck.

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.C.

answers from Anchorage on

If she was my sister I would let her stay with me, but give her a time limit, and help her get back on her feet. It would only be temporary for the kids to share a room, or she could share with the girl (which may encourage her to get her act together faster). I would not give her money, just shelter and a shoulder to lean on. I could not, in good conscience, leave my sister in a abusive situation simply because it might inconvenience my kids for 5 or 6 months, but that is just me.

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

D.K.

answers from Washington DC on

I agree with Melanie D. She's going to have to WANT to change, or it's just going to keep happening. Some people just have to hit rock bottom before they finally get their acts together. Your sister needs to find her OWN reasons to value herself and stand up for herself. As she is now, she's toxic and I would stay away and keep my kids away. I know you don't want to "bail" on your sister, but you're not, she "bailed" on herself long ago. The best thing you can do is continue to be emotionally supportive, but don't provide any other support. She's working, she doesn't have to hand her paychecks over to this guy. They're not married. If he takes her money without her permission, that's theft. Grand theft if it's over $5000. She can call the police. She has to WANT to. She has to get pissed and she has to start valuing herself and realize that she deserves better than this. She has to realize that she is capable of taking care of herself and she doesn't need a man. Until she does, there's nothing you can do.

1 mom found this helpful

M.D.

answers from Dallas on

Honey I know it's hard on you but the best thing you can do for your sister is make her grow up and stand up for herself. Until she does that, she'll keep falling back with these types of guys. She has to leave and there are places she can go. She probably doesn't want to go to a woman's shelter, first of all they have you press charges against your abuser, she doesn't want to do that. You wrote how she gave her car up, I'm sure you kept telling her she'll needs it, but she did what she or her boyfriend wanted her to do. Until she wakes up and sees everything how it is, then she'll stay and be miserable. I'm betting he's hitting her even if she doesn't admit to it, if he's hanging up the phone, taking that much control, she's being hit too... If she does have a job, she can take her paycheck get on a bus and leave everything behind, it's just material. When she has had enough she'll do that. I know you want to help and protect her, but she's has to be an adult now and grow up.
You could find a shelter in your area, church group that may take her in. Tell her take her next check and show she's done with this guy. That she needs to start fresh and show she's ready for a change and you will help her. Don't give up your kids room, let your sister prove herself, not only to you, mostly to herself. It's tough love, but she needs the backbone to stand up and make the change.
It'll break your heart that you feel you aren't helping enough, but this is why you have to be strong for her. She can do it on her own. Don't give her money. If she moves close to you, buy her a meal, or dress for work, but do not give her money.
I'm praying for you!

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

N.O.

answers from Dallas on

The ONLY way you should allow her to stay with you is if she cuts off ALL contact with him. If you don't feel she's going to do that, then don't allow her to stay with you. What's the point in you changing your entire life style around for her if she's going to stay in touch with him? and most likely she will keep in contact if she's stuck around this long.

You didn't mention how old she was or if she has kids. IF she has kids, she should be able to get into a shelter easier, but most women prefer an abusive relationship then living in a shelter. It may take HIM leaving her for good before she can move on. It's great you care so much for her and are trying to help but it's almost like trying to help an addict, until they're ready to get help for themselves, there's nothing you can really do. My own Dad has refused my sisters to live with him when they were in a bad relationship, only because he knew they would still be in touch with the men so for now, don't allow her to stay there unless you know in your heart she's completely ready to move on and start over and won't be a negative influence on your children when living in your house. Good luck to you.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.H.

answers from Honolulu on

She is being abused.
She has no friends.
She has no where to go.
She has no money.
She is in trouble.
She needs help....
She needs money to get away... before she is killed by him.
She needs money.
Give her what she needs. If that were my sister, I would do whatever I can, because I would NOT want her to be a "statistic."
I would also call the COPS on him... and take photos of her if she is injured.. .and DOCUMENT everything.
Get a restraining order.
Plan an escape plan and help her... BUT DO NOT TELL HIM.. or he will retaliate... and do who knows what else to her.
I would think she does get physically abused.... but won't admit it.

Call shelters, and find out information yourself, so you KNOW yourself, what can be done...

She has a habit of being with abusive guys... one day, she will be a statistic. High probability for that.

If it were you... what would you want? Help or no help?
And yes, it is tricky, because, SHE has to do it too.
She is REALLY chronic... and needs counseling... tell her she HAS TO do that... and make it a part of her 'requirements'...

all the best,
Susan

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

D.P.

answers from Pittsburgh on

IF (and this is a big IF) there are no drug or alcohol issues involved, I would let my sister crash on my couch for a set amt. of time until she got on her feet (say 3-6 mos. MAX).

If there ARE other issues involved (I only say that because it doesn't seem like rational behavior to me on her part pr his) then she needs rehab and she needs to leave him after that. She will see that clearly once she is de-fogged.)

There are ALL KINDS of resources out there for women that need to get away from a bad/abusive marriage. I think she's using it as an excuse for not leaving (the shelter comment). Has she ever CALLED and been told that point blank?

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions