A.B.
J.,
Potty training is (in my opinion) the hardest task a Mommy has to do when your children are toddlers. I potty trained boy/girl twins and told my pediatrician that it took me a year and a half to potty train them so my 2 year old would have to potty train herself! I was kidding, of course, but I was a frustrated mom during those years. My, then, 2 year old is now 5 and happily potty trained. There is hope!!!
Here are a couple of things I found successful: 1. I bought a candy dispenser and filled it with skittles. Every time my daughter went potty she got 2 skittles and everyone else (company included)received 1 skittle. She soon liked going potty. When the Skittles ran out - I told her that she was now potty trained. She still had a few accidents but pretty much it was true. 2. I had the kids watch Veggie Tales in the living room while sitting on the potty chairs. 3. I put them on the potty and then spent the next 15 minutes reading to them. 4. I set them on the potty with Magna doodles to draw with. 5. I set the timer for every 30-60 minutes for a potty break. When there was a success we had a party!
Never punish a child for going poopy in their pants but I would definitely tell them that playing with it is yucky and gross!
Also, remember you are not alone and don't let other mom's, grandparents, etc who didn't struggle with this critise your efforts. Shake off any guilt/shame/other's expectations/etc. Potty training takes a lot more time than you think it will.