do you have a bassinett? those things work good because it gives baby the feeling of being closely contained. in a crib its hard to acheive the same thing because you arent supposed to put anything around them in their cribs because of SIDS..
just a short piece on bedsharing (which isnt the same as cosleeping) - bedsharing is safer and more normal than you think! many parents choose to do this and it works great! it is normal for babies to like this, and its also great for sleep because you dont have to get up to nurse; baby can just get latched on and you will do it while mostly asleep. i understand your hesitance now, baby is only a week and a half old! i didnt start bedsharing with my son until he was 2 months old; we had him in a basinette until then. so just wanted to put that in there.
other things to help baby sleep without bedsharing is co-sleeping; which just means having baby sleeping in your room. there are ways to hook up the crib to your bed so that its like bedsharing but safer and more comfortable for everyone. heres a video description about how to do this! :) its really awesome and might give you the effect you are looking for:
http://www.drmomma.org/2010/01/turn-your-crib-into-coslee...
other than that, soft light, never use glaring lights (which is something you probably already know) white noise! my husband and i ran the vacuum pretty much all night long until my son was like 1-2 months old and we foudn and bought a WELL WORTH IT cd called "for crying out loud". it has 8 tracks at 9 minutes each of different types of white noise so you can find the sound that helps your baby sleep the best. obviously, our son loved the vacuum. so we made another disk (so we wouldnt ruin the original) of ONLY vacuum tracks. it worked great.
heres the link
http://www.amazon.com/Crying-Out-Loud/dp/B00000DAN0
dont sleep babies in a pack and play; they are unsafe for sleeping, and highly uncomfortable! i mean, with that bump thing in the middle, i cant imagine anyone being comfortable in them :\
either way, this is normal for babies to be more awake at night. just do what you can to remain quiet, calm and "sleep like" at night, and try to be more awake during the day. theres no keeping a baby this age from sleeping, and not sleeping when he wants to, but you can remain as normal as you can for yourself. the important thing isnt to listen to doctors, friends or us, but to listen to your baby, his needs, your instincts, and do what you have to do as a family. there is no shame in cosleeping (sharing a room) or bedsharing (sharing a bed) or doing the sidecar situation. your baby spent 8-9 months inside of you, hearing you breathe, your heartbeat; being out in the world isnt fun! the closer he can get to you, the closer he can be to your smell, your sounds, your heartbeat, the more comforted he is, and thats normal, and actually very helpful to babies! baby's heart rate and breathing are directly affected by hearing moms heartbeat and breathing too, so thats awesome. :) :)
dont let anyone tell you that something you feel is right for your son is wrong, or is spoiling. theres no such thing when you follow your instincts! YOU are the mom! you are the one who has to live with the results of any decision you make. that means that you must make the ones that are best for your family, no matter what anyone else says. also; to solve this problem; you dont have to answer to anyone else for anything either. if they ask you some question that you know you are going to have an answer for that they dont agree with, you do not have to answer, or you can say something vague like "its working out just fine thank you".
the more you listen to your baby now, the easier it will be to hear him later when tantrums start! LOL
anyway, write to me if anything i wrote is unclear. www.askdrsears.com is a great resource, and ive heard the "no cry sleeping solution" by elizabeth pantley (i think thats the right name?) is a great book as well. me? i bedshared and coslept with my son until he was nearly 3 and he is by FAR the best sleeper, and the most agreeable at bedtime of any child i have ever met. so theres no reason that any of those behaviors have any negative effects on sleeping habits later on in life.
anyway im blabbing. blag blab blab. sorry if i gave you info you didnt want :( :(
my biggest message is to trust yourself for the answer. only you know what is best for your family.