Need Help with My 3 Year Old!!

Updated on November 23, 2009
M.H. asks from Lima, OH
6 answers

My 3 year olds dad was never there for him until 11 months ago. My husband has been there for him since he was born and he's who he calls daddy. well, his "biological" dad now gets him every other weekend and lately when I pick him up on Sundays he cries that he doesnt want to go with me he wants to stay with him and his girlfriend and it makes me soooooooo mad and hurts my feelings. I don't know what to do, it's so embarassing when he whines to stay there it makes me feel like I'm doing something wrong even though I think I do a great job and I don't think I'm doing anything wrong. Is this normal??

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

So What Happened?

Thank you all very much!!! It makes me feel alot better and makes me feel like I should keep doing what I'm doing. Thanks for taking all the time to respond to me, god bless you all!!

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.C.

answers from Dayton on

Your ex gets to be the "Disneyland Dad". Your son gets to go there and be treated. There probably isn't alot of discipline or rules because he doesn't want to spend the time with him in a negative way. They probably also do special things since it's only every other weekend. I have gone through this for the last 18 years, and especially the last 10. My 2 older sons are from a previous marriage and for the first 10 and 8 years of their lives, even though their dad lived no more than 20 minutes and sometimes as close as 7 minutes away, he was never there on a regular basis. He missed birthdays and holidays. He was very inconsistent but when he was there is was like spending two days at the circus. He lavished things on them. But then all the other times the boys would fall asleep on the sofa with their coats on and their bags next to them and he would never show up.
I got married to a man who loved us enough to make all of us family. At first it made no difference other than to make my ex seem like a spoiled little boy who was getting his favorite toys taken away. Then he met a woman who made it a condition for being with her that he be a better more consistent father. All of a sudden Disneyland Dad was on the move. In the meantime, my husband was the real father. He took care of them when they were sick, coached their little league, played in the yard, helped with homework and gave them guidelines and guidance. Their biological father never did that, but if he got up and tied his shoes he was a hero. It was hard a lot of the times. Parenting is thankless on the best days, but this was like being slapped in the face almost.

Things to consider are these: Even though he came in late and this is frustrating for you, it is so much better than your son suffereing the rejection he would feel if your ex had never stepped up. As good a dad as your husband is, it would not have covered for the fact that his biological father rejected him. The main reason he doesn't want to go home has nothing to do with how good a M. you are or how good a dad your husband is. It has everything to do with the fact that he is having fun and that he assumes that everyday would be like the weekends even though you know it wouldn't be. Little ones tend to romanitcize the part time parent and put them on a pedestal. The have ideas of what it would be like. It will be like this when he gets older too. "If I lived at my dad's I wouldn't have to (insert unsavory chore here)." The important things is that YOU know better.

Lastly be comforted in the fact that when he gets older and is better able to see the lay of the land he will KNOW who parented him, who loved him, played with him, taught him. Like the wash it all comes clean in the end. So just be patient with him and keep your head up. This time is just a season in a really long life. It gets better.

L.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

T.G.

answers from Dallas on

I think that going somewhere for 2 days out of every 14 is kind of like a vacation. Anywhere that is different from home is a little "cooler" than home to a child. Plus, his Dad probably makes the stay a bit more special than any other day beause it's short-lived. I understand that you feel hurt and angry, and I think anyone would, but don't blame yourself or think you are doing something wrong just because he doesn't want to go back home. It's not your fault. It's also not his fault for wanting to stay. I don't want to encourage bribery, but you could start a routine every time you pick him up - some special time spent or maybe his favorite dinner, so he looks forward to coming home. Also, I would calmly discourage whining. It's a button pusher for me and it sounds like it's one for you and he might know that and be taking advantage. Make it clear that no amount of whining will get him what he wants. Good luck!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.E.

answers from Evansville on

Maria, I feel your pain. My last 2 children, now 19 & 17 would cry to stay with their dad. Your son is little and doesn't know what is best for him. You do. I believe it is normal.....bio dad has him 2 days every 2 weeks and probably gives him his way on most things. He has that luxury. You on the other hand, have the glorious job of educating, discipling, nurturing. Just keep loving him when you get him back and trust that in the end, he will appreciate you. It is so hard being a good M. but trust in yourself. If that is the worst embarrasment that he puts you through, Thank God! Take it easy on yourself and enjoy your son.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.G.

answers from Cleveland on

Maria,

My hubby and I are still together... so my situation is a little different. But when we take the kids to Grammy & Papa's to stay the night or weekend, we have the same issue. You see because they only spend a very short amount of time with them, they get more attention then at home and it's just one there not the whole gang (I have 3), so it is easier for them to give them extra attention and save up to do all the "fun" stuff you might not be able to do because your funds are going to care for them (clothes, houseing, school supplies, food, extras).

In time your boy will see the difference... remember in life the grass always looks greener on the other side, but it ususally isn't.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.B.

answers from Cincinnati on

Totally normal. My Neice just did it to my M. yesterday, and my son's brother does it to EVERYONE he leaves!! He cries and cries for 15 minutes when he exchanges care givers, and always wants the person he is leaving. Both are three.
My neice wanted to stay with my M.. She even went as far as saying she didn't love daddy anymore, she only wanted her Granny. My M. was in tears!!
It could be the rules are different there. Maybe she has more freedom or is allowed to eat/drink different things making it the "more fun" house or maybe it's that she misses him since she spends less time with him. It could be anything.

Reassure her she can call if during the week if that's ok, and she will be back to visit in # of days. Make the pick up quick with hugs and kisses good bye to all.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

B.B.

answers from Indianapolis on

It's normal. My husband and I are still together, but my oldest daughter sometimes wants to stay at the sitter's because she's taken on another child who my oldest wants to stay and play with.

You're doing a great job, but like someone else said, biological dad gets to be "disneyland dad" - all the toys are "new and fun" and all the activities are different and new, so of course, he's having fun. It should be a good thing that his biologican dad is taking such good care of him that he wants to stay there. It's hard to see it that way though.

Maybe you could find out what sort of things biological dad is doing, and do things like that too. Not that it's a competition, just that obviously, whatever they're doing is having a positive effect, so maybe whatever they're doing you can do too, or gain some new ideas for stuff you guys to do too.

Just a few thoughts, for what it's worth.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions