I'm a luddite, aesthetically, but I do like certain creature comforts.
I want:
Indoor plumbing, but candlelight/gaslight/kerosine, not electric light.
Bicycles, trains, and steamboats, but few if any cars.
Jazz/blues/ragtime, but no electronica, musically speaking
Books and newsstands everywhere you see. Theater, incl. vaudeville, but no TV.
This puts my eccentric self squarely in the Edwardian era (just before, and maybe during, WWI). This was also the beginning of the Progressive Era, politically, so I'd fit in ;). Of course, I want to live in this era without having to live with its social inequalities, i.e., the Jim Crow system in the South. When you scratch the surface, time travel does become a lot less appealing. I still want gaslight, blues joints, and train whistles, though.
Mira