Hi L....I am a reading specialist in DuncanvilleISD and the concern that you have is a great one. I am so happy that you understand your son's needs enough to recommend retention for him. This is an awesome task and one that many parents refuse to take. I have the tough job of sitting down with parents year after year and explaining that their child might face retention at the end of the school year. I've had parents break down crying, go to other sources because they just can't accept it, and even pull their child out of our school! What I've realized is that it's very hard to have someone tell you that basically, your child just isn't where he or she needs to be. To a parent, it means you've done something wrong and that is not always the case. Your husband needs to realize that every brain is different and has different needs. While you and your husband may have been head ot the class, straight A students, that is not necessarily who your child is. It's all a part of wanting the best for your child added with a little denial. I recommend that you speak with your school's counselor and the reading specialist if the school has one. If your son seems immature and not ready for first grade, please hold him back. He will be a much better student if you give him more time. By the way, when's his birthday? After 8 years in education, I know for a fact that most boys who have summer birthdays have a hard time adjusting in school. In most of those cases, we almost always recommend retention. Feel free to email me. I'd like to know how everything works out for you guys.