Hello C.,
I am saddened by your story. Please do not take offense however, I cannot say I agree with your assessment that he is good Dad. I am one of those children who parents fought all the time in front of my brother and I. I was a very sick child till I was about 11 and the only time my parents paid attention is when I started turning blue because I could not breathe. I still 46 years later cannot not handle people yelling around me or at me. I hide and avoid all conflict.
My "mother" I use that word loosely finally divorce my father because he abused her and us, but she left us with him to raise. I am sorry but I still hear the fighting and I still overeat when ever conflict or stress is involved.
I have dated 11 men in my life, and married two of them and I realized I married someone and dated all men just like my Dad and I was becoming just like my "mother". I left my husband that day and took my children and never went back and I stayed alone for nearly 17 years till I could choose someone that would not treat me that way.I can promise you this I made sure that my daughter would never be abused and would fight in front of the children. My daughter has been a Mom since she was 16 and Kody just turned 14 and never has she or her x husband had a fight in front of the kids, never.
These kids need a voice, their parents are not willing to speak for them according to your letter. You must speak for them. Your niece in her condition should not put on weight. Your nephew needs to be healthy. It is time for you to call child protectives service. Abuse is not the only reason to call them. They need help and the ball is in your court now. If you were not truly and honestly worried about them you would nothave come and talk to us.
Please maybe you think at my age I should be over most issues and yes I went to therapy and I can deal with all things but yelling and conflict but I still remember the fights like it was yesterday, I cannot make that pain disappear. I have learn a better way to deal with it.
Stop the cycle for your neice and nephew now. Stop the cycle. Yes your brother is grown up and yes they are his children but it seems like he is not taking a grown up approach to fatherhood. It seems more like you and your other family members are taking the grown up approach to raising these childen. Never give up on the kids, never give up your brother but get him pointed in the right direction.
M.