Omg, they are the picky couple.
And not culturally broad in outlook.
They seem to be about stereotypes.
But feel they probably know, everything.
Environmentally conscious people or lifestyles, are not all like that.
They, as first time parents probably don't even know what they want or need, but probably go according to top 10 lists or something or according to brands or what is trendy at the moment. And they are persnickety... and probably think that raising a baby is like a book and goes like clockwork. Egad! LOL
Once they have a baby, their world will either flow with it or they will get confounded... because their baby does not operate like a book nor like clockwork.
Get them a book about baby development.
"What To Expect The First Year."
AND get them a book about the Toddler years, because as we know, those Toddler years are hard! And kids do not behave like a preconceived plan. A child, has their own personality.
Is the Mom breastfeeding?
If so, get her a "Boppy Pillow." That is GREAT! I LOVED LOVED LOVED mine. I nursed both my kids.
Don't get them clothes, the parents seem picky, and probably only want high end brand names for the baby.
Not "Walmart" as you said.
Get them, board books, CD's with soothing music, a mobile, a soft cuddly baby friendly stuffed toy, a "Eurobath" by Primo to bathe their baby (I had one and I could still use it even when my kids were much older. I LOVED this bath).
Get them "green" toys... toys made with eco-friendly materials.
What is buying them something fabulous mean??? Is it per monetary amount or about the brand??? They seem to value brand names.... and the cost of things... the more the better????
Get them a special Wedgwood or Waterford Christmas ornament, for their baby's 1st Christmas.
Or a nice high end eco-friendly made Christmas Stocking with their baby's name embroidered on it.
Or something that is culturally meaningful, to them.
A "family tree" type gift.
Or things like this:
http://www.itsonlynaturalgifts.com/Organic_Baby_Gift_Bask...
Or a nice high end baby photo album that is embossed with the baby's or family's name in gold.
And then, stuff all of these things into a cute nice basket.
(sorry I'm just venting, but..) Ya know, comparing American children to other children culturally... for me is so, icky. ie: I have in-laws that are from Europe, they say things like that too. And my kids, are better behaved than their kids and have more manners than they do and are much more verbally expressive in a succinct way, than their kids are. Sorry, it just irks me. Nothing personal against you. Your In-laws, are like some of mine. Don't know why they have to compare American kids, to their kids.
Or Google Search "eco-friendly baby toys."
I would make a basket, with stuff in it.