L.M.
not exactly what you are looking for but baby showes would be the best shower for using alternatives to gift wrap.
am i assuming right about baby shower and not a bridal shower??
you can use a baby bathtub to hold tub gifts and top with a towel to unwrap stuff.
you can wrap an outfit in a recieving blanket,
you could give a pretty basket filled with board books.
you can fill a small laundry basket with outfits and detergent and not even tneed to wrap it.
IS that was the friend is thinking??
If she just doesn't want you to waste toilet paper wrapping her in a tp wedding gown that should be easy enough to drop and find a different game,
like name that tune or something and the players shout out answers instead of writing stuff down.
just another thought in my part of the country we eat play games and then watch her open gifts or play as she is opening, After the gifts are done we are done, to stick around to play with the wrapping paper seems a little strange to me. in the time progression. of the party.
Does that help??