Ok... A couple things I did to make my oily skin manageable... I also had an extremely oily back, neck, and bottom.
To "tone down" the oils all over myself, I did the "fake n bake" only once a week. I wasn't going to get a tan... I was trying to dry the excess oils. Worked like a charm.
On my face... The ONLY thing that helps is the Apricot Scrub for normal-oily skin. I just buy the store brand stuff. It's right next to the more expensive tubes. Same ingredients.
I also use a water based, extremely light weight moisturizer (I know, it sounds rediculous, but really... it does help). It's by H2O Plus. It is a little pricey, but it works SUPER AWESOME for oily skin. It's called Face Oasis. I have to buy it online, but totally worth it. They have a great skin care line as well. You definitely get what you pay for with them. Also made in the US... In Chicago.
Good luck!