I agree with both answers so far.
I stole a 5 stick package of Juicy Fruit gum when I was about 10. I had to return the last stick and pay for it. I earned the money by washing and drying dishes for my parents. It took me about 5 weeks to earn the money at 2 cents per WEEK of washing all the dishes we used. (Family of 4) I sweat over that 5 stick package of jucy fruit gum and I didn't even get to chew the last stick. My day and mom both talked to me. The store manager "talked " to me. I never stole another thing, except my wife's heart. ;-))
When my 8 or 9 year old daughter stole lipstick from a grocery store, I took her up to see the store manager. He took the lipstick and told her he couldn't sell it because it had been used and told her how much it was. She asked again how much it was. I told her she could borrow the money from me, but she would have to earn it back. She pulled weeds, picked up trash, washed dishes, fed the chickens and gathered eggs. It took her just over three weeks to earn a stick of lipstick. To the best of my knowledge she never stole anything again. My other kids learned from what happened to her and I didn't have a problem with them either.
Good luck to you and yours.