what do you do when he does this?
i would go on about my business calmly. if he screams while you're in the shower, well, screaming never killed anyone, and his dad needs to learn how to deal with it calmly and matter-of-factly too. i like to keep a melting-down baby close by while i'm busy with something else so i can give an occasional sympathetic pat but not attention, no persuading or pleading or attempts to fix. the noise is obnoxious, but that's not a baby's fault. and if you're leaving, go. his dad is a big boy. he can handle it for a few minutes while baby lets it out then adjusts to your absence. which he will.
when you pick him up, he's smiling and giggling because he's got his mommy whom he adores with him, not because he's 'getting what he wants'. babies are in the moment, not schemers. don't project that pejorative attitude onto him.
you don't have a strict no paci policy if you give it to him at night, but not really. you have a squishy senseless paci policy. either take it away, give it to him, or always let him have it at night. it's not a comfort to him if he's anxious about whether he's going to get it or not, and right now he doesn't ever know whether he will or not. you don't have a set time he can learn that he'll get it, you arbitrarily grant or withhold with no rules he can figure out. if he needs comfort, give him a paci. if you hate them, don't give it to him at all.
i mean, why ever let him have one if you're not going to give him one when he actually really does need a woobie?
khairete
S.