J.L.
Well for my 2 year old I just get whatever. This year we are getting her a Mr. Potato Head and a bunch fo little things (bracelets, sidewalk chalk, plastic bat, recorder, candy, etc). I am planning on making one for my 6 year old niece i'm getting her fingernail polish, fingernail decal/sticker things) a special pair of earrings (its the one year mark of when she got them done) and some candy.
When we were growing up my mom did baskets forever! When we got to the point of over 18, she just got us an easter card and a gift certificate in it (chili's music stores, movie tickets, gas card, grocery card, bed, bath and beyond, walmart, target, etc). I always thought it was kind of cool to still get a gift. =)