K.M.
Hey Colleen!
We have a very dependible teen age babysitter, who lives right across the street so her parents are always available too, just in case. We have 2 little ones (age 2 and 6). We pay her depending on the age of the child and whether she is watching 1 or both. For the 2 year old alone we pay her $7 per hour as he is far more intensive to watch than the 6 year old. When she watches the 2 we pay $10 per hour. At the end of the day, I say whatever you feel is "fair" and will help you to keep a good, responsible sitter, providing you with peace of mind when your away is all that matters.