Hi J.! I hear you about taking the fun out of it having sex on all those days - getting-pregnant sex is not always carefree and fun! What I did was chart my temperature to see exactly when I was ovulating, while also looking for ovulation signs like cervical position and mucus (I know, lovely). With both my pregnancies, my most fertile day was between days 14-16 so we had sex all three of those days, or at least days 12, 14, and 16 at minimum. Once my temperature shifted higher AND the ovulation signs were gone, I knew that month's window had closed and we had done all we could. If you want to learn more about this natural family planning type of method, I highly recommend the book "Taking Charge of your Fertility" by Toni Weschler. At the very least, you learn a TON about your body in general, no matter where you are in life. Good luck with trying and do have as much fun with it as you can. It can be tough when you are thinking about an outcome, so try to relax and it will happen. :)