Hi J.,
I've raised six kids (two adopted) so I potty trained four. My opinion? boys are much easier, my daughter was a challenge. She would sit on her potty, looking at a book...im ready to give her M and M's , stickers whatever, she can't go..she stands up and pees right there in the floor, smiling at me....ohhhh sooo not fun.
So I took her to visit preschool....and we talked about how only big girls with NO diapers and NO pull ups could go there. Bought those thick white panties, with the middle panel. I found that pullups wicked the moisture away from her and she felt dry so she just peeded in the pullups and didnt care.
probably a month or so later, i noticed she was dry more often...then we went to regular panties....she occasionally had accidents but not so often. we talked about preschool alot ;) maybe that helped!
B.