I have used Haggen's bakery for several birthday cakes for my two children. They do a great job matching your colors or designs, and of course you can choose from a book with lots of popular characters. The cakes are always delicious and we get lots of compliments. The price is reasonable, too. For my son's first birthday, they did an additional, complimentary small cake (about 5" round) for the birthday boy to dig into. I don't know if they still do that, but it was a wonderful surprise.
Happy Birthday to your little one.