Oh my...this is only one example of how rude and selfish and insensitive so many people are becoming. My 20-something daughter gave a party while in grad school, and several said they would come (one being a guy who is still her great buddy, many years later), and one girl even called just an hour before the party to ask the address (she had been to the apt. once before, and it was quite near, but just needed the address), saying, "See you soon!". Guess what? NOBODY SHOWED UP AT ALL! So, at 10 P.M., with hors d'ouvres and drinks wilting, my poor daughter went to bed. This cannot be blamed directy on these people's parents, or maybe it can, with the way they were brought up. And wait until you send a $200 wedding gift and never hear a word! Then you tactfully, three months later, ask your friend, the bride's Mom if her daughter received it, and are told,"Oh, yes! I think they are doing their thank-yous this week!" Then a month later, again, tactfully, in an email on another subject, you drop in the question to the bride herself, "Oh, by the way,did you receive the gift I sent" (this being 4 months after the wedding). Her reply was, "Yes, I got it and am enjoying it, along with the OTHER beautiful things I received! Didn't my Mom TELL YOU already that I got the gift?". She added, "We are still 'looking for the right thank-you cards', and the wedding etiquette book said I have six months to send thank-yous' " . Can you believe anyone (and from a "classy" family, to boot) would somewhat argue and defend oneself in this situation, instead of just saying, "Gee, I am so sorry I have not gotten my thank-you cards out, but yes, I love the bedspread" - then following that up finally with a proper thank-you card?. I never received a card,by the way, and it is five years later. This was a family we had been close friends with for many years, throughout our children's school years, all of us visiting each other often, etc. Well, the son of the family married a couple of years later, and yes, I got an invite for that one, too. But I didn't send a gift. Why bother? Gifts are given, not to receive praise (or a thank-you card), but you want to know that they liked it, and (and if it even got there from the store!), and it is simply expected, as well as a common courtesy, that the recipient acknowledge the gift within in a reasonable time. Bottom line, and I have digressed, but as it relates to your birthday party for your daughter, people are becoming extremely self-centered and ruder in general and are tossing aside all social graces, I find. And yes, if your situation about the party had happened to those moms (i.e., not having received an rsvp response, or just a lame excuse), you can be sure they would be bad-mouthing you! But you, it seems, are a rare one these days - one who still shows class and a sense of fairness and sensitivity. Your little girl's sadness makes me sad. I went through a lot of that with my daughter, beginning in kindergarten (the k'garten little girl "leader" brought toys to school to give away to make friends...and she then had those 'friends' lock my daughter in the rest-room every day). It didn't take long for me to go to the school principal about this one! Good luck with your situation. Keep "taking the high road", even though others don't so much. Hopefully, you and your daughter will find a group of reliable, true friends soon, but it's hard! I hope somehow her future birthday celebrations are happy, memorable ones!