Dear D.,
First I suggest Arbonne Men's shave gel while reducing the nicks, the gel will help to condition the skin. You may also be having a reaction to the products you've been using,thus the redness. Just because a product works today, it may not work tomorrow. Our skin changes due to enviroment, foods we eat or medications we take. Next, make sure your legs are warm before you shave. That way you don't cut the skin. Waxing will get you a nice feel to your skin. However, you will experience in-grown hairs! OUCH! as your hairs grow.
Please email me @ ____@____.com for more information regarding Arbonne. K.