I agree with Jill. Both my sons, now 8 and 5, attended Willow Creek and loved it. The director Sandy and her assistant Sarah are the best and I've loved all the teachers my boys have had. Hours are 9-1 with early drop off available at 8:30 and stay n play available until 2:30 on Tues/Thurs (I used this 1/wk at the end of their 4 yr class to help get ready for the long kindergarten day).
I have friends who also love Tuscawilla Presbyterian (TPS) on Aloma. I toured Oviedo Baptist, New Covenant, TPS and Willow Creek and picked the one that felt best to me. Just go with the place that makes you feel most welcome. I think they all have great reputations - just go with your gut. Also, it they're full, get on the waiting list if they have one. People move so spaces open up.