Potty Training a 3-1/2 Year Old.

Updated on January 18, 2010
C.S. asks from Green Bay, WI
4 answers

I'm at a loss with my 3-1/2-yr-old son. He just refuses to use the potty. He's dry all night, goes on the potty first thing in the morning, then will go in diapers, pull-ups, undies - even tried no pants around the house - he'll stand and go on the floor!. And he's pooped on the potty a number of times, but still tells me "he doesn't know how to poop on the potty" and will go in his diaper constantly, even if he's just been on the potty... we've tried sticker charts, marble rewards, he even has some Rescue Heroes sitting on top of the fridge right now... he wants them soooooo badly, but not enough to go where he's supposed to. He's a smart kid. I just can't get through somehow. He has a 14-month-old little brother and a 4-yr-old big sister - we talk continuously about how the baby goes in a diaper, but big kids (like his sister) go on the potty... and he seems to be completely on board, until it's time to go... then he just refuses. He will sit on the potty, tell me over and over that he doesn't have to go... then 5 minutes later, he'll go in his pants... my daughter was sooooooo easy... and I know boys are supposed to be harder... but THIS hard?!??!!!.... any tricks that have worked for any of you would be so appreciated... thanks so much...

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

E.C.

answers from Minneapolis on

I'm in the same boat as you...Dont give up: ) Boys are much more difficult to potty train! I take my son to the potty, I don't wait for him to say he has to go, cuz he won't tell me! He also uses the floor as a toilet! If he doesn't go when we are in there than we just come back in 5 minutes... I set a timer so that he knows. Only use underpants during the day, if he needs a pullup/diaper at nap/night then only use them then. Its can be really draining to have to be the one to take him in there all the time, but I figure he will get the hang of it eventually...(I HOPE!!!) Consistancy is the most important part. Also make sure that anyone that is going to be watching him knows the scoop too!(babysitter, grandparents, dad). I told my husband from day one of potty training, If he has an accident it not his fault its ours because we are the ones that need to get him to the potty till he catches on! Well best of luck to you and your little guy! It will happen it just might take a LOT of hard work: )

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.B.

answers from Bismarck on

I wonder if he is using this as an attention getter. He may just be pulling your chain because you react! My son...years ago now...was easy to train and totally trained at 18 months...guess I was just lucky.

What if you just ignored his behavior...put him on the potty and then if he doesn't go...let him go in his pants...change him and don't say anything about it to him, but maybe talk about it in front of him to someone else like his dad and just say to his dad, the neighbor, etc. that some day he will grow up and be a big boy but not say it to him so he understands that he isn't getting your attention by going in his pants. Good luck!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.M.

answers from Charleston on

You could also try getting him excited about a camp or class and tell him only kids who know how to use the potty are able to go.

B.W.

answers from Minneapolis on

Boys aren't harder to train. Starting too late makes all kids hard to train.

I would very nonchalantly toss him a rag to clean up his own mess. Don't get riled up, but make him take time out of his playtime to clean up the mess, and then clean himself up, get himself new clothes. Once he realizes you aren't getting worked up and giving him the attention, it won't be his 'win' anymore. I wouldn't clean up his mess. He obviously knows what he is doing, and at 3.5yrs old, he surely does and this is for attention and a power struggle. Make him clean it up, and walk away. He will soon realize its easier to just go in the potty than to make a mess and have to ake 1/2 hour out of his playtime to clean it up.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions