D.H.
She might not be ready, but before you wait a couple of months, try getting her stickers to put on a poster on the wall or buy some $1 toys and give her one each time she actually goes to the potty. If that doesn't work either, she just isn't ready.
I potty trained both my boys at 2 1/2 years old doing hot wheel cars. They wore underwear day and night. But my now 2 1/2 year old daughter isn't ready at all. She does NOT want to sit on the potty. Some kids just aren't ready. Try again in a few months.
If this has been a frustrating time and she sees it, it's not a good thing. It shouldn't come to the point of frustration.
As far as the pacifier...my daughter was the only one that took one and what happened was sheer luck for us. She misplaced her paci's. She knew it and couldn't find it...we were all looking for it before bedtime that night (this was shortly after she was 2yo). Anyway, we honestly couldn't find it (I found them the next day though, but she didn't know it...I threw them away). What we did was just say, 'we can't find it', it's 'gone gone'. She accepted it. She did ask about once a day for the paci, and we just repeated it everyday. She did fine though. I was surprised because she was actually taking the paci all day, every day. She asked everyday for about a week or more and then stopped. She was a bit restless at night, for a couple of weeks, but that's about it.
You could try and 'misplace' it on purpose. But remember, you have to get rid of them so YOU won't be tempted to give in when she's really having a problem. Good luck!