Potty Defiance

Updated on November 02, 2008
A.C. asks from Vancouver, WA
4 answers

Hey ladies! I have a friend who has potty trained her little 3.5 yr. old boy. He recently started using the potty, then stopped doing poop on the potty, and now is being very defiant about it all. He will stand in front of her and poop in his diaper, and when she says something, he will look her in the face and say...yeah, I went poop, and I'm going pee too, and then laugh. She is on maternity leave for a few months after just having a new baby and her husband has been gone on work trips alot, so it is obvious he is acting out maybe because of so much change in his routine, but She is getting worn down, and is doing this all alone as husband is gone so much. Any ideas or suggestions?

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

More Answers

M.B.

answers from Seattle on

A.,

There are a lot of factors here. 1) Daddy is not home, 2) Mommy is otherwise occupied, 3) an interloper just arrived and 4) he feels like he has no control of his environment. It is very common for older siblings that are potty training or recently potty trained to regress back in protest of the new arrival. My son did this when my daughter was born 19 months ago.

The best thing to do is to let it be, put him back in diapers and wait a few months and start the potty training process over again. If she tries to force this issue she will only get more frustrated. This is all about power, and HE has the power, not us.

Hope this helps,
Melissa

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

A.L.

answers from Seattle on

He is acting up because of new baby and dad being gone a lot.
He is old enough to know better. Give him lots of hugs, tell him you love him just as nuch as the new baby. He is your "big boy" now. He needs to be put in underwear not diapers at least during the day.
When he goes poop in his diaper or underwear, stand him in the tub, tell him to remove his diaper/underwear, turn on the water for him, hand him a wash cloth, and tell him to clean up. Then give him new diaper/underwear to put on. If he just pees, then have him remove wet diaper/underwear and give him new diaper/underwear to put on himself.
Praise him when he goes in the potty instead of his diaper/underwear.
My daughter was slow to potty train because of having younger brother and being lazy. She was completely trained by 3.5 years.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

P.M.

answers from Portland on

I think Melissa has outlined the problem well. A new baby in the family is often the cause of potty problems - if an older child can be more like the new baby, he intuits that maybe he'll get some of the attention he has lost. He doesn't like the situation he has been put into by the adults and circumstances in his life, and body function is the only thing he feels he has any control over.

If pottying behavior doesn't get the results little siblings hope it will, occasionally kids will go on to act out in other ways, with eating disorders, breath-holding, tantrums, or other destructive behaviors. They are are too young and inexperienced to be effectively strategizing. They simply go with the first thing that gets a reaction from their parents.

So it's really going to be most healing for all family members if these poor, stressed parents slow down and interact with great patience and love toward their little guy. He's hurting, feeling lonely, abandoned, displaced, frustrated and perhaps even unwanted (his own emotional interpretation of events – I'm sure his mom still loves him dearly), and he's confused about what to do about it.

At his age, he simply doesn't have the perspective to see that he might have other choices that would give more positive results. This is the only snippet of power he's managed to discover.

This is where parenting has a chance to shine. If the mom can possibly find it in herself to spend more time snuggling, talking, asking the child about what he needs (this can be a slow revelation over many little talks, because he's just confused right now and thinks he's mad), she might find that life becomes happier for not only her son, but herself, too. Sometimes positive change starts right away.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

B.O.

answers from Portland on

Everything that I have read says that he is going through a developmental stage of realizing his ownership over his bodily functions, and the products of those functions. I would suggest to acknowledge that he is going poop with praise for him telling you that he is going, then remind him that the poop does belong in the toilet.(While you are helping him put it into the toilet from the pull-up or diaper) My daughter is 2.5 and won't poop in the potty hardly at all, she says she likes standing up to poop:) But she will get on the toilet to let me wash her butt afterwards.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions