S.C.
My first suggestion would be to not do what I did and go w/ the first one you meet! Ugh, big mistake, especially w/ the end of preg. care...
Anyway, had have "shopped around' I would have found a better one that perhaps our insurance probably would have covered (the one I 'picked' didn't take insurance at all, but she was highly recommended by a friend of mine... should have shopped around)
Make sure you check references!
Check their certificates
How long have they been "in business"
How many times do they go to the hospital for various things (some are necessary things that a midwife is making a good decision, so look for that and also if she has made mistakes)
Um, check how close they live to you
How many pre-natal appointments do you get and what is included in them
What do you need to buy for the birth
Check what the post natal care is
How do they feel about shots and such,
Religious beliefs too (I did have a Christian midwife, one of her good points)
If I think of anything else I'll let ya know!
Congrats on the baby
And even though I wasn't entirely fond of my midwife, and I did end up at the hospital, I'd try to homebirth again if we were to have another (which we are not)