K.R.
I was working for a health insurer when I was first pregnant; I tried to stay in the system but it was just too dangerous (I was working in medical statistics, and it was just not justifiable, the risks and standard 'treatments' that hospitals assume/require ... even though it is SO much better than it was 40 years ago!). So I got pushed into the midwife route because I wouldn't bow down and let the system decide there was an emergency when cleary there wasn't, and at the time I felt very betrayed ...
... but I am SOOOOO glad I got pushed out !!!!!
Our first two kids were born at a midwifery clinic two minutes from a hospital (partly to assuage relatives' fears about me Not Being In A Hospital), the last two were born at home. I wish I had been brave enough to birthe at home the first two times as well ... so many less stressors = SO much better birth experience. Plus, you _really_ don't have to move, and all your own food is of course Right There. I did all four births dry (although my first labor was 38! hard hours and for about 6 of those hours I was in the jacuzzi tub in jut candlelight, which was very nice--but not for the birth), so can't speak to the birth tub.
Our midwife costs in 2000 were something like $1200, which we (painfully) paid out of pocket and which included all prenatal and 6 postnatal visits (the midwives don't want women to put off prenatal care to 'save money,' so there is no discount for starting late ;) ). But not lab tests (the insurance did pay for those) nor ultrasound (I didn't do ultrasound, which now finally is starting to be exposed for the un-safety-proven technology it is, and for its suspicious confluence with the rise in autism-spectrum disorder in industrialized nations around the world ... every once in a while, the mainstream media catch a whiff of that forbidden secret ... GROWL ... ). Thatyear (2000), the Oregon Health Plan paid for a friend's midwife birth at a clinic (so maybe they still do), but wouldn't pay for homebirth, but my big-medicine plan of course didn't pay for either (sigh--it's safer and cheaper, but of course a threat to their whole concept). In 2000, a basic hospital birth at a high-end maternity ward in Portland started at about $5200, if nothing set off any non-basic tests or treatments (that $ number I had from inside the system).
In 2002, the midwifery birth clinic birth was $1500, but Lifewise paid for it (yay Lifewise! truly "wise"!). The clinic had to charge $2100 to get the $1500, of course--insurance billing is tricky : P.
In 2004, there was a big drama because we had No Money and I was trying to figure out how to make the insurance work for me but not be sucked into the hospital system. I don't remember what we paid in the end (for our homebirth), but not very much, because a midwife I knew granted me a BIG HUGE favor--and my husband, perhaps finally believing I was (very) serious about laboring and delivering in the van in the hospital parking lot and only going into the building if something seemed to be going wrong, decided we could go a little bit in debt to have an attended birth at home instead. An interesting side note, though, that I learned from a nurse midwife after the hospital tour (when all the non-problem mothers had gone away and couldn't be scared by me ;) ), is that the midwives on Native American reservations are (of course) not bound by all the legal stuff the affects state-liscenced midwives ... she offered to connect me to a Native midwife she knew who would take barter for payment. Since we were poor, I considered this, but really we had nothing much to barter ... so I was glad I already knew my midwife, and she trusted me enough to take me on something like only two weeks before I was due!
In 2007 there were new big dramas (my husband left), but I'm pretty sure the price was $2500, paid out of (our) pocket(s) because our current big insurer of course (sigh!!) wouldn't pay for the homebirth ... I think the last I heard was that a basic hospital birth costs something like $7000 ... but that's a vague memory, as I wasn't exactly actually 'in the market' for hospital services ;)!! Thank goodness my husband was still capable of listening to reason about it not being fair to not give this baby all the statistically supported chances his older siblings had had. I did (since I was essentially abandoned, sigh ... ) break down and panic a couple of times and go in for ultrasounds, to make sure the baby was still alive. I wish I hadn't, and I will try to maximize anti-autism health choices Just In Case, but there it is. Nothing like being off-balance to cloud one's judgement!
Anyhow, those are the $ numbers I remember.
However, I'd say: make the decision about where you will feel safest, because that is where you should labor. I have lots of friends for whom the 'safest'-feeling place is a hospital maternity ward. And I don't bother them about it (really! ;) ) ... well, unless they ask me to ;) ...
If your insurance won't pay, ask yourself how much it is worth to you to do it the way that you feel is best for your family? How much support (financial, emotional) do you have from the people around you, and is it enough? What medical risks balance how much financial risk/effort to fight with the insurer? How many fears will be assuaged one way, how many the other?
For the first birth, standing more or less on my own about my non-hospital, let-her-go-late choices was very very(!) hard. It would've been nice to have the actual (not just the nervous verbal) support of both families. That might have been worth a large amount, actually, except that I was very sure I would end up in a C-Section if I stepped foot in a hospital (which as it turned out I definitely would have) ... and that would have erased completely the relative worth (to me) of the family support.
Anyhow.
If you choose to go with a midwife, find a midwife you trust. They seem to come in two basic flavors: mother (which was great(!) for my first birth) and fellow-woman/friend (my preference later). Often you will choose one midwife and she will call one or two others as assistants/backup, and if you hire her early in your pregnancy she can get to know you a bit first and better choose the team so they are women she suspects you (and your partner, if applicable) will work well with. All of that is included in the total cost. Usually one midwife is an apprentice putting in her hours toward her certification, so you get to hear the teaching and take delight in her discoveries, which are sometimes your discoveries as well :).
May you have a blessed pregnancy and birth--and everything beyond :)!
--K.
PS One thing I kinda feel like midwives don't realize you should be warned about ... after every birth, mine asked if I wanted to see the placenta. Ummmmmm ... NO. No, not really, thanks ;). From hospital-birth friends, I gather this is not part of the medical routine ;). My midwives were very into the Beauty of Birth :) ... and actually, by number four, I was used to the idea and recognizing that it might be my last chance, and I did ask to see it. And it was cool (really cool!) ... but I'm really glad I didn't for the first three, because I really _wasn't_ ready, and seeing it for number four really confirmed that :P!