Partial Weaning for a One Year Old?

Updated on April 15, 2010
K.E. asks from Broken Arrow, OK
5 answers

So my son, 1 today, seems to be weaning. I've been feeding him solids since he was 6 mos, and just in the past month or two he's really slowed down on breastmilk intake. Frequency and length of feedings are shorter. He goes to daycare 2-3 days a week, and recently she's told me he usually won't take a bottle (pumped or formula), sometimes he snacks on it a bit but only ocasionally does he drink a full bottle. He definitely nurses the longest at night, for naps (when home) and when he wakes up, but the rest of the day when he's home he only nurses a few minutes here and there. He knows the sign for milk and uses it quite frequently. My older sister who has 3 kids suggests I stop pumping and he'll either stop nursing as it dries up or maybe continue just for comfort. However I'm a little hesitant to do this. I have been substituting some daytime feedings with just milk in a cup (pumped, formula or cows), and have asked the daycare to do the same, to start substituting for nursing. So I guess I am really assisting the weaning process... However, when he's home he still signs for milk frequently and I usually nurse him partially because it's easier for me and I want him to be able to nurse however long he wants to. In fact I'd rather continue it and not have him take cups/bottles or drink cow's milk (too late I guess for that), but that doesn't seem possible because he needs an alternative when he's away from me. Also a big thing is he recenlty has been waking up frequently in the night and can only go back down after nursing. I would like to break him of that. Am I confusing him by sometimes substituting for nursing and sometimes not? How can I break him of feeling the need to nurse every time during the night wakings?

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

So What Happened?

Wow thanks all for the very helpful advice! It's amazing to receive so much BF support too. Don't know why I didn't think of dropping formula, but it makes sense now that he can have cow's milk. He is doing great drinking milk, water and juice from sippy cups. And most of the time during the day when he signs milk I offer him the cup first instead of nursing. Before I knew it one day I realized he had gone 8 hours without nursing! So he is down to about 3-4 nursing times/day, the rest is liquids in a cup. He does occasionally drink pumped milk in a bottle and I am continuing to pump just once while he is gone at daycare. So I think it's a combo of him weaning on his own and me offering alternatives more often. He is also doing great with eating regularly, 3 meals + snacks so I know he doesn't need much else.

He seems to be sleeping better now that I've adjusted & been more consistent with his sleeping schedule, still awaking occasionally in the night but usually only once. I think part of it was growth spurt and also I found out he was getting sick, had a cold/congestion for almost 2 weeks. I do try to just comfort him back to sleep which sometimes works, but if not I will nurse him back to sleep.

I do only have one other question, how do you deal with it when you are away from home with your child? I still tend to resort to nursing, or offering him a snack, if he gets fussy when we're out (he doesn't do a pacifier). Do you always carry around a sippy cup with milk - how do you deal with keeping it cold/fresh etc? What are your favorite travel cups?

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

M.K.

answers from Stationed Overseas on

This actually sounds pretty normal to me. My breastmilk dropped dramatically around 14mo and that's when I started to wean and do the switch over to cow's milk. I think you need to either go formula or cow's milk while at daycare so as not to confuse him and then just breastmilk at home since you want to continue to BF which is awesome by the way. Don't let daycare give him any subsitutions and you should do the same while he is home during the day to keep it consistant. He will drink when he is thirsty. If the waking at night is a new thing could he be teething? Sometimes nursing can help soothe those sore gums. Try teething tablets and rock and hold him for comfort he may not be hungry at all but just needs some comforting.

1 mom found this helpful

A.S.

answers from Dallas on

Nursing him to help him sleep at night has a psychological answer. He uses nursing to self soothe and also if you are nursing to put him to sleep in the first place, often times when children wake up in the bed surroundings, but remember falling asleep in their mom's arms, it can be confusing to wake up in bed, so they will need the nursing to get asleep again.

It isn't usually a hunger issue that they need the night time nursing at this age, but a comfort issue. You can still nurse during the day or night as well, but try cutting that last nighttime feeding and it will really help.

Instead of nursing him when he wakes at night, hold him, cuddle him, sing to him, rub his back, though it would probably be more effective if instead of picking him up, you go in there and gently rub is back/tummy/hair or whatever he likes. It may be rough the first week or so, but he will learn and the next phase will be easier.

I nursed both of my boys until they were about a year and a half and this really helped me cut the night waking as well.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.O.

answers from Detroit on

at one year my son only nursed before nap, before bedtime and when he woke up in the am.. and if he woke up in the middle of the night..(he often woke up in themidle of the night until he was 2 years old.)

we always nursed upstairs in the rocker in his bedroom.. he never asked to nurse anywhere else..

I would stop pumping.. pumping is a pain. especially if he is not drinking the milk you pump. let hime nurse at the normal times but switch him to a cup of cows milk. he should be getting milk with meals and with snacks.. I dont think this confuses them.. they get a cup with milk for meals.. nursing is a difernt thing.

he will enjoy the bonding closeness cuddling of nursing.. it is not about food at this age.. it is comfort.

as you wean you will eliminate feedings until you are down to bedtime only.. then that is the last to go.

if you do it gradually your son wont miss it and you will not become engorged.

K.C.

answers from Barnstable on

First off, let me applaud you! You say "I usually nurse him partially because it's easier for me and I want him to be able to nurse however long he wants to" so you are allowing him to dictate the speed and timing of his weaning. It is as nature intended, so bravo!

All babies naturally drop off their nursing times BUT they also become professional boobie-nursers! They can draw out 5 ozs of milk in 5 minutes and you can release it that fast as well!

As long as you nurse him when he asks (and the fact that he tanks up at night), you will maintain your milk supply.

What I would do is pump once during the days he is at daycare (so you won't get uncomfortable) and you can use that milk to make healthy snacks for him (breastmilk can be substituted for cows milk in most any recipe!)

You are doing a fabulous job at letting him nurse when he wants! He will naturally and slowly wean himself!

:)

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.T.

answers from New York on

Well every child is different, but I nursed my daughter until she was 23 months, and she drank cow's milk during the day. Up until the day we stopped she nursed before bed and at nap time.

I was able to SLOWLY stop the middle of the night nursing by making sure she had a snack before bed (usually cheese) and then I slowly increased the time between each feeding, I also made length of each nursing shorter. Yes - she fussed and cried, but she did get used to it for each change. At the end we did go cold turkey, but after two days she stopped pulling on my shirt and then after a week stopped asking all together.

I don't think you can confuse him - he can tell the difference, he just might not know how to communicate it. With my daughter I taught her a sign for Mama's Milk for nursing and just the regular milk sign for cows milk.

Anyway, good luck!

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions