M.P.
I haven't used the Soothie's because my son wouldn't accept any paci, but I LOVE the Avent bottles and playtex Ventair bottles. I suggest buying just one bottle of Avent and try it out for a week or so. These are super easy to clean so it's not a big hastle. I only have one right now because I'm switching over to Avent. My son has a huge mouth (like mommy's) and the Avent works well with him and they come in a billion sizes. Bottle and nipples.