This is just what worked for me, but it was successful and I now have 4 kids who sleep through the night and my hubby and I get sleep and alone time too...makes for a happy home and calm kids.
So, I used the book "On Becoming Babywise" by Gary Ezzo. Again, some people as you said have a problem with crying it out, but I can't tell you how it helped me.
Babies need their sleep and sometimes they get into a pattern where they are stuck in waking at certain times each night/early AM and this method helps to kind of break that cycle so everyone gets sleep.
You work towards the schedule and don't beat yourself up if you go off of it, but it's been a miracle for my entire family and even when I've had friends disagree with letting the baby cry, they really only cry for about 5 min. and then they learn to "put themselves to bed" instead of being rocked, nursed, etc...to sleep...if you start those habits now, you have to break them later, so it's just a decision to make now so you get off to the right start and know what you are getting into. My friends try and do this method after they are tired of whatever they were doing and it's much harder to get the baby sleeping on a schedule as they get older.
It's really whatever works for your family, my hubby and I decided before we had kids (based on seeing what our friends had done) that we didn't want our babies to sleep with us. We're very close and we adore and love our children, but we need our space and no one really gets "real" sleep if you are sleeping together...anyways, off on a tangent, but you get the idea...it's an easy read, worth trying if you don't mind them crying a bit before they fall asleep.
I've coached other mommies through this method, so feel free to email me if you have any questions or concerns..I love helping with this stuff.
C.
____@____.com