Hi W.,
I too, had the same problem. Then finally, I came up with my "Popsicle Stick Chores".
I use regular popsicle sticks, and write a "child friendly" chore on the end of the popsicle stick. I put the ends in a cute mini-vase that my kids gave me for a present a long time ago (that I rarely used before).
When it is time to do chores, each kid simply pulls out 2-3 popsicle sticks, and those are their chores for the day. It's fun for them, because they don't know their chores until they've picked the sticks out of the vase.
I use it when we have "down time", not on a regular schedule. Mixed with sports and homework, it's hard to "plan" when they will have time to help around the house as a responsibility. But when we DO have time, we simply pick out chores.....even I do, to join "the fun" :O)
As they get older and more capable, I change the chores to meet the capabilites of my boys. Some chore ideas in my house, on the sticks, are:
* Clean Baseborads in Living Room (use clorox wipe)
* Clean all windows sills in house
* Vacuum Family Room
* Organize Wii drawer
* Pick up everything on floor of Family Room
* Throw the ball for Max 20 times :O)
* Clean all door handles in house (clorox wipe)
I have about 20 chores in my vase right now. I leave the one's that were picked out until the end of the week (whenever that is!).
I try to have chores that aren't too difficult, so they are helping without the moaning :O) They are little chores that help me immensly, yet are easy enough for them to do by themselves, no matter who picks the chore.
Other things that my boys do "solo" are maintenance chores. If I see their rooms "overwhelming", then I say, you need to pick up everything GREEN in your room (or whatever color I see most). This always leads them to clean more than I've asked because the "green army men, went with the army trucks, etc....).
Anyway, W., I LOVE my popsicle vase of chores because there is no chart involved, no stickers to keep up with, and it doesn't take up alot of room, and I have nothing to keep track of any longer!
Your boys are at the age when my boys LOVED my ticket jars ;O) I bought a $4 roll of tickets to use as rewards. If they did ANYTHING that made me(or themselves) proud, I encouraged that behavior constantly by telling them to go put 1 ticket in their jar. It worked for my 6 yr old to sleep in his own bed, too, of course I had to give 3 tickets for every night he stayed in bed :O) Anyway, once they BOTH reached 30 tickets, we would go shopping for their reward. They knew what my budget was, and we worked with that. I still have my ticket jars, and they still work great for their ages. My new Jr High kid was overwhelmed with the transition of several classrooms, and homework form each one of them. He did AWESOME with those responsibilities this past week, so I rewarded him with 5 tickets at the end of the week as a surprise. He has 2 more to go to catch up to his "eager to get a prize brother" who already has about 40 :O) I guess I'll be shopping this week. I liked my idea (long ago) about waiting for BOTH of them to have the 30 tickets, because they actually began helping eachother to acheive their goal of getting a prize :O) When they were younger, I was able to buy and WRAP gifts for "picking" when they reached 30 tickets. It was easier for me then, to NOT have to go anywhere waiting for them to FINALLY pick something! I already knew what they wanted anyway, so I would get it on sale. I'm behind on that, though, so I'll have to be patient shopping with them this weekend.
Well, W., I hope something I do in my home can help you figure out what will work in your home. Keep trying things, because eventually you will find something that works for your boys. Have fun!
~N. :O)
P.S. Oops! I just read the rest of your posting about homework. Here's my "2 cents"......First of all, please make sure that when you get home, he has the same routine. Drop his backpack off at the "homework station" (wherever that is in your home). Then tell him he can relax and have a snack for 25 minutes until the microwave timer rings. Then we will start homework. Routine is KEY for introducing a constant pattern for years to come. I even carry "homework supplies" in my van, in case run out of time at home to finish it.
My 6 yr old had a hard time "being motivated" to do his homework last year, so I began this routine. It was mostly him feeling overwhelmed. I had to come up with ways to "prepare him" at home to make it easier for him. Like Spelling words. I knew on Monday that he had to write them 5 times each, so I made him a chart (table) on the computer and wrote his words FOR HIM the first time, instead of him going back-and-forth from paper to paper. It was easier for him having it all on one page. He had to write spelling sentences on Wednesday, so I asked him to give me a sentence for the word "tree", and then I would write the sentence down. When Wednesday came, he simply had to copy my sentences that HE already made for himself. This reduced the feelings of being overwhelmed AND it kept him independent (and he didn't feel like I was helping).
Now starting 2nd grade this year, he knows what I expect of him, and he his doing "the routine". Without being asked, he drops his backpack off in his room then asks me for a snack. I really don't use the timer anymore because he KNOWS what is next.....homework. This year, I have barely helped him, as he has been very independent, so far (Praise the Lord!). I think it's because of our hard work establishing a routine in 1st grade.
I hope that helps. :O)