Need Help with Toddler in Permanent "Opposite" Mode

Updated on June 28, 2010
M.M. asks from Paso Robles, CA
9 answers

My almost 3 y.o. son seems to be going through a phase where no matter what you ask him, he answers with the opposite of what he really wants. For example, if he has cereal for breakfast he'll say "No milk!", so I'll say "Ok", put the milk in the refriderator, he'll say "Want milk!". Or I'll ask him if he wants to go to the store with me, and he'll be adamant about NOT going, until I get my keys for the car, at which point he'll then want to come with me.

Pretty much it seems any choice he is presented with, whichever one he initially chooses he changes his mind immediately. This ends up with a lot of tantrums, tears and misery for all, especially because in the last few days I've been following through with whatever his first choice is and he has *not* liked that, but it hasn't changed anything (I guess I was hoping he'd start to see the consequences, but I was wrong).

Is this a typical phase? Has anyone else gone through this? Is this just a control thing (for him and heck, me too??)? What did you do? Thank you in advance for your input, Mamas!

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

So What Happened?

I really appreciate all the input. Thank you very much! We've actually simplified things and it seems to be helping (asking very specific and simple "this or that" questions). What I appreciate most is hearing that other parents are also going through this - crazy that is so comforting but it is. Thank you all again for your input, I feel I have good advice to ride this "phase" out :)

Featured Answers

C.B.

answers from Kansas City on

you're right - this is a typical phase, and it is a control thing. try to lay back about it, he will get past it. he has realized he is allowed to have a choice in matters and is excercising his control. be patient! this too will pass :)

****
updated:
i literally just had to ask my son THREE times if he wanted mayo and mustard on his sandwich. i finally had to stop him, get him to look me in the eye, and say, "do you want mayo and mustard? the white and the yellow stuff?" and he started fussing saying, "no! i don't like those!!!" he had just told me - TWICE, that that was what he wanted, even though he doesn't even like them. he just wasn't listening at ALL to what i was saying. that could be part of it, too.

3 moms found this helpful

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

D.S.

answers from Tulsa on

this too will pass. its an age thing. when he is older you will look back and remember how cute it was. I know its not cute now but trust me in 10 yrs you will laugh about it. good luck and count to 10.

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

I.G.

answers from Seattle on

Oh my gosh, tell me about it. My daughter is going through this right now and it's driving me INSANE.
What sometimes works for us is that I count to three, by which she has to make up her mind, otherwise I make the choice and we stick to it!
This too shall pass!
Good luck!

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

N.B.

answers from Toledo on

I think you need to practice following through with his choices by offering choices on everything possible. Which shirt today? Which shoes today? Which cereal today/ which cartoon show today? As he learns to live with the small choices, he'll stop changing his mind so much on the ones that are bigger. Gently remind him as he's choosing that it's final. And if you don't want to live with his choice, don't allow him to choose. Don't ask "Do you want to go to the store with Mommy?" if you can't leave him. A common one is,"Are you ready to go now?"We don't realize that to him, that is offering a choice. He says no, and we're all over him because we want to go. Think what you're really asking him before you speak so he's not confused.

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

C.O.

answers from Sacramento on

He is wanting to demonstrate his independance in the only way he knows how. Unfortunately, he ends up making choices he doesn't want at the expence of the "independance". Try giving him big boy things to do, besides choices, and allow him to demonstrate his independence in other ways.
Also, continue giving him choices, but make the small and limited for now, "Do you want to wear the green shirt or the blue one?", or "We are going to the store today, do you want to help mommy with the list, or do you want your own list?" Try to give him choices that are not to drastic. For a three year old, to have milk or no milk is a drastic question ;)
Hang in there. It will pass.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

P.M.

answers from Portland on

Yes, it's about control, and desire, and the inability to really satisfy either. Not only do kids have to adapt to their parents' needs and requirements most of the time, but even when they are offered a desired toy or activity, they don't necessarily have the motor or language skills, or simple experience, to make the most of it. Or they are already in emotional overload, and can't readjust when they actually get a choice.

Consequently, toddlers often lead mind-bogglingly frustrated little lives. A process called Emotion Coaching is effective. Toddlers will still be toddlers, and sometimes they just have to rage. They will have little impulse control for a few more years. But to the degree you can empathize and help them name their frustrations and unmet needs, they begin to realize you genuinely care about their predicament. That can be almost magically calming and supportive.

Dr. Harvey Karp, author of The Happiest Toddler on the Block, models one type of emotion coaching here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fJ1428uYs2g&NR=1&f...

There's also a very fine book that helps parents understand how to emapthize with their children's emotional needs: Raising an Emotionally Intelligent Child by John Gottman. Children whose parents practice "emotion coaching," as a group, are more physically healthy and emotionally resilient, less affected by stress, perform better academically, have better relationships, and are less likely to develop behavior problems.

You probably already pay attention to this, but kids will do best when they are rested enough, not hungry, and not overstimulated/rushed. Some kids are also extremely sensitive to household chemicals and/or food additives, which can trigger mood swings or sleep difficulties in addition to physical problems.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

A.P.

answers from Los Angeles on

Maybe you don't want to give too many decisions to make. It may backfire in the near future when he's 4 & 5 and doesnt want to do thing because he thinks he has a choice in everything. Perhaps be cautious of what he does get to decide on and how that will set a tone for the future.

1 mom found this helpful

R.G.

answers from Los Angeles on

OMG!!! lol that is too funny i have a boy who will also be three real soon and he does the same thing!! what i do is just talk to him like the example you did. i'll ask him do you want to go to the park? and he will say no! so the i dont take him and he says mom park! then i tell him if you want to go to the park tell mommy yes mommy i want to go to the park! sometimes i feel like he doesnt understand or like he's like ok yeah whatever but i just keep talking to him. if he is being a nice boy i will take him to say the park in the example above but if he is misbehaving and just being a little meany then i wont take him to the park and i let him know that he said he didnt want to go there fore we wont go. i do see some improvement and he seems to do it less as i keep working on it but it definitely is a work in progress, i just think to myself if i keep this up he will get it ( sigh)!! it'll be great to see the responses to other ways of dealing with and i would love to hear what happend... i know its not such concrete advice, i just thought i'd let you know you are not alone.... good luck!!! oh i forgot, at first my son will play with me saying yes no yes no, but when i see where he is going i let him change his mind once after that i will not give in to him cause he will play me!!! lol we're the moms not them!!!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

X.W.

answers from Atlanta on

he might not know opposites. just keep prompting him with which is opposite and which isnt. It's a stage, I promise. My daughter does exactly the same thing. She is also 3 and a half years old and it is 'wearing' off from her. just ignore it when you can. just learn what he means by his opposite.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions