A.T.
I just replaced the one my 5 year old had on his bed because it was plastic, and I bought one at Target that is water proof that is 'fuzzy', not that plastic covering.
He actually seems to like it better, as well. No 'crinkling' noises when he hops into bed, yeah know?
Hope that helps! Target is a great place to find the simplest things! I found it in the Bedding Area.
Good luck!
~ A. T. ~