My Almost 3 Yr Old Is Lashing Out!!

Updated on December 19, 2009
J.T. asks from Reston, VA
9 answers

Hello moms,
My almost 3 yr old has developed a severe temper, and a disregard for authority. He's hitting, screaming, saying no to everything, and doing the opposite of what we tell him to do. He didn't go thru the terrible two's yet, and i'm wondering if this is it? I've tried different techniques for discipline when he does this, but its not working! The first thing I did (from Supernanny) is the 1,2,3 magic and time out. He's doing something that he's not supposed to, and i'll tell him to stop, or get down (he's a climber) and let him have a chance to stop. He won't, I say in a stern voice, 'That's 1!'. I'll tell him again, and if he doesn't, 'That's 2', sometimes he stops before I get to three, but if not, he's promptly to the time out chair for 2 min (since he's 2 yrs old) and the 2 min stops when he calms down. Afterwards he offers to say sorry and then I talk to him in easy language about not doing what he did. Then about 10 min later, he does it again!!! He's hitting his older brother, and the other night, he hit me with a high heeled shoe. After he did that, I did not count to three, I put him directly in time out. He is still defiant though! To top things off, he's been climbing on things to get to what he wants, he climbs up on the counters, in the pantry, everywhere. He's figured out how to open the child proof door handles.

I don't recall my older son going thru this quite so badly when he was the same age. Does this sound like the terrible two's to you? Other than time out, what discipline techniques have worked for you?

1 mom found this helpful

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

So What Happened?

To all of the great and wonderful mommies that responded to my plea for help, thank you so much!!! I am so very thankful for the great support that I have received and great ideas and advice. I'm taking everything into consideration, and am going to change my hours at work so I can be home more, i'm going to stay consistent, and try some of the techniques that you sent to me. Thanks again!!! and Happy Holidays :-)

J.

PS. our furniture is L bracketed to a stud in the wall, so my climber won't tip anything over.

Featured Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

N.B.

answers from Washington DC on

It sounds like you are using the 1,2,3 Magic the way it was intended and he is learning from it. I think you just have to keep doing it. It sounds like the "terrible twos" in full swing. They repeat behavior over and over at that age. They test you to see if you will stay calm and be consistent. I think you are doing all the right things. I know it is hard, but I think if you continue, his tantrums will eventually happen less often and last for short time periods. Don't give up!!! Just remember No Emotion and No Talking. That is key!

1 mom found this helpful

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.C.

answers from Washington DC on

I understand that it's difficult for you because you work full time, but you need to spend more time with your son. You are away from him all day and he is clearly just trying to get your attention - positive or negative. My advice would be to re-arrange your morning or evening schedule so that you can actually sit down on the floor with him, even if only for 15 minutes, for uninterrupted play time. Just you and him. He wants that from you and needs it from you.
He also needs routine, a predictable schedule for the day. Uncertainty of the days events breeds anxiety and all children react when they feel anxious. Don't you? You could let him know what's coming next maybe 10 minutes ahead of time, even if you have a schedule, so he has a little bit more control of his day.
And by all means - remain calm. Even during the prelude to a timeout.
Your child has a good heart, he's not mean or terrible, he is just reacting on his emotions. You're doing a great job. Keep up the consistancy and encouragement.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.N.

answers from Washington DC on

Something's very possibly wrong physically. Careful on the spanking advice, because think how cruel it would be if he's acting this way because something's hurting him. This is how children act when they're experiencing chronic low-grade pain. He may have headaches, or his stomach hurts, or his nerves are all inflamed. They get hyper to distract - they don't feel good if they're not being hyper. They can't hear you because they're having to manage. He could have sensory problems - if you're raising your voice, that might be painful to him if there's something wrong. They don't know how to handle when the sensory input from an external source, like another person, is painful. (For example, I can't think, my brain shuts down, if my kids are throwing fits). He's not going to listen to grownups if he's in pain and no one's helping him or comforting him or making him feel better. He's not going to tell you he's in pain, that he feels lousy, because he doesn't know that's what it is. It's not clear-cut like a boo-boo. See an osteopath, a reputable alternative doctor. Have him evaluated everywhere that you can. Follow clues until they deadend. Look hard for diet problems. For example, celiac disease (gluten intolerance) can very much cause this (gut issues cause pain, inflammatory processes affect the nervous system). Doctors have been slow to clue in about celiac.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.H.

answers from Richmond on

my sister became a champion climber at that age, so i know
how it is.. married or not. think of putting the stuff the
child finds attractive in a place they are not going to look,
cookies in the tool drawer.. why not, the child isnt going
to be looking for cookies there.never tolerate aggresive behavior in a child, because sooner or later the child will
get bored of throwing things at a sibling, and they will start throwing things at you.i have seen too many people
tolerate aggression in little boys and then wonder why they
have to put the emergency room on speed dial
K. h... brand new mommie

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.A.

answers from Norfolk on

Hi! Our boys are about the same age difference;) My oldest was the sweetest baby, but he was a rotten toddler for what seemed like forever! My youngest is 2 & 1/2 & the complete opposite. He screamed for what seemed like non-stop as a baby, but has been relatively pleasant (so far...) as a toddler. The major difference between the 2 are different fathers (the oldest's dad was never around to help me lay down the law) & of course I'm much older now. I've seen that you must follow through now, or you'll have more discipline problems later. It's just a phase I think, but don't let him get the upper hand! We do time outs as well & I think they do work-even the 9 minute ones for my big boy;) Toddlers are learning, testing boundaries & their own strength & probably enjoy watching objects sailing through the air.
Also, recognize that the little one probably idolizes his big bro, so make sure he's a good influence. We have to separate the two often when they act out to make sure proper lessons are learned & they don't feed off each other.
Plus, if you're working a lot, he may be needing more attention from you & he doesn't know how to ask for it since he's so young. Good Luck!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

R.W.

answers from Washington DC on

Wow...do we have the same kid?! Ours is turning 4 next month but his 3's have been awful. Nothing works. Time out, Magic 1-2-3, taking things away, sticker chart, throwing toys away, etc. We even tried spanking but he didn't care and laughed at us so we did stop using that technique. We still do the above other things but it's so frustrating b/c he still doesn't listen. We obviously can't just let him get away with being bad so even though we feel like broken records, he still gets a punishment. He'll sit on his bed during time out and not move and stay quiet as a mouse. Then as soon as we open the door he goes crazy again. When we take things away from him he says - that's ok, I'll get it back another day. It goes on and on. Unfortunately, my only advice to you is to keep doing what you're doing and one day it will sink in. He was a complete angel when he was 2 so this is definitely his terrible 3's.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.C.

answers from Washington DC on

Me do it is coming soon. It must be programed into us to want to be independent. Someone said give her lots of loving. I would like to offer a concrete example of that loving. Give her two choices whenever possible. Instead of giving an order "Put on your coat." Say "Would you like to wear the pink sweater or the gray hoodie under your coat." My favorite right now is "Do you want to go right now or in five minutes" (read that one on Mamasource I believe - It works!)Anyway - here is something I have been trying to keep in mind - the way we talk to them now is the way they will talk to their friends and the way we train them to react to us is how they will react to their friends (do we want them obeying their friends without question!?!). We need to teach them how to make choices. Anyway - works for me (unless she is super tired or hungry!).

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

T.M.

answers from Washington DC on

I think you are doing great! It takes repitition for them to finally "get it" Just keep doing what you are doing - I know it's hard - and he will eventually calm down. One thing if you aren't doing it though - praise him - a lot- during the times he is doing the good things. Another thing I could suggest when he is hitting - like biting - pay more attention to the injured party than to what he has done - tell him he has done something that is not very nice and he has hurt brother or mom or whoever and take care of their wound. Have him help so he can see what he has done. Some of it could be an attention grabbing thing. He is trying to show he is becoming independent and you are doing a great job from the sounds of it in showing him what is not acceptable.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

H.B.

answers from Washington DC on

dear J.;

my heart goes out to you. my daughter works with children who manifest the behavior as your 3 yr. old. there is a name for this behavior , it's call ODD, a defiance disorder. you can google it for medical information & how to deal with it. it may be worth the search. i wish you success.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions