I am a makeup artist and can make some suggestions on this topic :)
A few of the products that I have tested and use both professionally and personally are Nixie, MakeUp Forever, and Smashbox. You can find Nixie online at www.nixiecosmetics.com. The latter two lines can be found at Sephora. These products are high quality, well pigmented products that I think you would be happier with.
I have many product lines that I use in my kit including drugstore brands, but these are my favorites right now. I don't strictly use any one line, different brands just have different items that I use and like. Also, I don't sell any products because I want my clients to feel I am making fair, unbiased suggestions :)
I could make a better assessment as to what specific items are better for you to maximize usage if I understood your makeup regimen, how much time and product you use to put makeup on, your skin type, etc. Feel free to private message me if you would like a more detailed personalized assessment :)