M.K.
Sounds exactly like my daughter. I was always at a loss because everything I thot she'd like, she didn't. So I finally just told her I needed some ideas. If she still believes in Santa then tell her he needs some ideas. I got both my kids a portable DVD player - mainly for in the car because we travel a lot and it kept the peace. But they loved having them in their rooms also; I just had to set some rules. A gift card to some place like Claire's or Icings in the mall - she loved that because she could pick out what she wanted. They sometimes have these sales where you can get like 20 items for $5 or $10. Just be prepared because it can take awhile to pick out that many items! lol!! Does she draw? A sketchpad of her own would be nice with special art pencils. Fuzzy socks are usually a winner. Does she like to help in the kitchen? Maybe a pretty apron of her own. I just had my mother-in-law make one for my daughter out of John Deere material. She loves it! If none of this works, maybe ask her friends what she wants; little girls usually tell each other before they tell their parents. Good luck and Merry Christmas!!