JFF: Mayo or Miracle Whip?

ONLY mayo...

also, ONLY sugar/honey... ONLY butter... and so on.

ALWAYS the real stuff and never the substitute! :)

Hellman's (or Best Foods as it's called in some states) is the ONLY mayo to use. I think Miracle Whip is called that because it's a miracle that anyone likes it.

We have both, Miracle Whip for me and Mayo for everyone else. She can't trick me either, I can smell it from the living room when she opens the jar, ha!

Mayo!

and real butter.....omg!

Mayo! And REAL sugar, too!

Mayo! Miracle whip is yucky!

Hellmans.

But I use it to make aioli. In fact sometimes I make homemade mayo from scratch.

:)

Definitely Mayo lovers here! And.... it can't be just any mayo. It HAS TO BE HELLMANN'S!! (Even their reduced mayo is so delicious!)

OMG! Time to come out of the closet! We were Miracle Whip all the way! I'm a complete embarrassment to all my NYC friends! ;)

It's the only way I will eat tuna fish or cold turkey sandwiches...

ONLY Best Foods Real Mayo!!! Yummmmmmm :-)

Mayo! Cannot stand that sweet taste in my savory foods.

raised on Miracle Whip.

ONLY buy Mayonnaise! Hellman's or Kraft. No store brand - tried it and it was different.

ONLY MAYO!!

Mayo from Trader Joe's is DELICIOUS. Plus it is all-natural and doesn't contain any preservatives! :-) We love it.

Miracle whip contains many chemicals. :(

Real Mayonaise - full fat kind....and now I like the Olive Oil one too.

Mayo. Preferably Kewpie brand from Japan.

Mayo - Hellman's or Dukes. Miracle Whip is disgusting. bleh!!!!!

Best foods (Hellmens)

Mayo. But only me. My daughter won't touch either.

Mayo. I don't know if my kids have ever had miracle whip as I think it's horrible and never buy it.

I dont like to have around either one although i really do like "vegenaise"......but mayo is better on sandwiches and miracle whip is better in deviled eggs

If I'm putting on a ham sandwich (the only sandwich I would put it on) then it MUST be Hellmann's.
For potato salad, macaroni salad, etc....Miracle Whip.

I like mayo. Husband and children like both.

Mayo - and not the lite stuff either. None of us can stand Miracle Whip.

Mayo. Hellman's or homemade. Period. My mom accidentally bought Miracle Whip once, when we were kids. It is 35 years later and we still have NEVER let her forget it.

Who are all these people who eat both? I have NEVER met one of them in real life?

Lowfat Best Foods Mayo is all we use.

Mayo, and preferrably homemade. If I buy store bought, Best Foods, but I prefer to make it at home, so much more flavorful!

Can't stand miracle whip, ugh.

Neither :P

I refused to buy the stuff....GROSS!

My husband like one of them...I could not even tell you which one though:)

The smell turns my stomach:)

We only eat real food, so homemade mayo is the only way to go! Can make it fresh with all organic, non-gmo ingredients and no sugar or preservatives. Yummy!

Real mayo. I grew up with that and have only used that.

Updated

Real mayo. I grew up with that and have only used that.

Miracle Whip! Kraft, the light kind.

99% of the time Hellmans Mayo

Every now and then I'll use MW to change things up. I don't use more than 1 small jar of MW a year

I buy Hellmans by the 64 oz container from Costco everytime I go to Costco. I keep the mayo stockpiled!!

Mayo, and it has to be Kraft. Dont like Hellmans or Miracle Whip.

Miracle Whip!!!!!!!!!!!!

Miracle Whip!!!

I never never eat cold creamy pukey salads, maybe if i did i'd like hellmans but eeeeeewwww. miracle whip is great on sandwhiches!

Mostly mayo. Every once in awhile I like a tuna sandwich with miracle whip. It's sort of a guilty pleasure.

Both. It just depends on what I'm putting it on!

Miracle Whip... I prefer the tangy taste, but even then I don't like globs of it. Nutritionally, one has more fat, one has more calories. So, they both are unhealthy wastelands. Mayo is the more 'pure' condiment.

Helleman's a/k/a Best Food on west coast. In Europe I use Tommy which tastes more like Helleman's. Miracle Whip like all Kraft products is full of chemicals and tastes of it.
I just plain cannot eat any junk food since I was a small child.

We love mayo! But I guess it also depend's, for my potatoe salad I do use miracle whip....But we love the Kraft mayo especially with french fries! Yummm...

I use both, depends on what sammich I'm makin.... and what my taste buds are wanting. I've been using vegonnaise lately tho and really like it. But a good ol' bologna sandwich with miracle whip, iceberg lettuce, pepper and thick amount of miracle whip is one of my favorite comfort foods. We use more mayo than miracle whip tho. I use miracle whip with a little milk and garlic powder for salad dressing fairly often.

Neither for me I'm all about the mustard

The men however prefer Hellmans Mayo

Miracle Whip is banned

Mayo. Except in tuna salad and oddly, to dip artichokes in. I know, weird, but I love it.

Although I know it is made of garbage, I pick Miracle Whip over mayo. BUT, recently my sister introduced me to some Marie Calender's All Natural salad dressings, so I have been using their ranch dressing instead of miracle whip.

Vegenaise, healthier and tastes better!

My partner says Miracle Whip,I say MAYO.

Hellman's Mayo here...but Hubby likes Miracle Whip too, so we have both. I have become accustomed to adding just a dab if I am making tuna for a sandwich for myself (along with pickles in there) for some tweaky flavor, but its the ONLY thing I use it for. The Miracle Whip container is this teeny little thing next to the GIANT Sams Club size Hellmans Jar in our refrig...LOL.

I always tease hubby with the lines from the older trash bag commercial when I pull them out of the fridge when we do sandwiches...I say "HEFTY HEFTY HEFTY....wimpy wimpy wimpy!" He gets mad then laughs every time!

fat-free Miracle Whip.....except for my chicken salad!

BestFoods / Hellmans!!!

(Same mayo... same label... different words East Coast and West Coast)

MAYO.

And the Olive oil ones are just as good. :)

Mayo and it HAS to be Hellman's. Miracle whip is just gross.

I switched to Hellman's when I was pregnant and haven't looked back since.

Miracle Whip! has more flavor!

Duke's Mayo...no sugar.

Miracle Whip Lite!

Dawn