Dear M.,
I used to be sure to get something for my husband for Valentines, and then be disappointed when he did nothing in return. After several years of this I decided that I should stop getting him something, because that made it all the worse when he didn't reciprocate. To be honest, I think it is the man's job to initiate Valentines Day giving! And I think it's just fine for him to do something and the wife to do nothing.
The problem is that "Hallmark, etc." causes us wives to have great expectations, but it also causes men to be more resistent, because they don't like for "Hallmark" to tell them to they have to do something for their wives.
Here's my advice: On Valentine's Day, don't do anything. If he does something, anything, APPRECIATE IT!! If he takes you to a concert, BE GRATEFUL!!
The Bible says, "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you." You want to be loved the way that makes you feel loved, right? So you really want him to do the thing that you asked for (Melting Pot). So, love him in the way that he wants to be loved. That's doing unto him as you wish he would do for you. How do 99% of men want to be loved? That's an easy one: Sex! Give him the gift of sex. Give yourself to him "to have and to hold, from this day forward." And give up your expectations of him.
I've been married 32 years, and truly, my husband hardly ever makes a big deal out of Valentines. But that's OK. He's a great husband, and I know he loves me, and he's romantic in other ways.
Hope that helps.
J.