How Do I Wean My Almost 2 Year Old

Updated on November 14, 2009
D.M. asks from Merrimack, NH
6 answers

Hi!, I am hoping you all can help. I have breastfed both of my kids. My son was very easy to wean as he was such a good sleeper, he weaned easily at 19 1/2 mos.(he is now 4 1/2) My daughter will be 2 at the beginning of December, and she still nurses 2-3x a night, and morning's and naptimes and nightime, before bed. she likes to graze on days we are home all day (like today, my son is sick) so she just wants to nurse for a couple minutes and says "boobie, please mommy, please" and how do I say "NO" to a cute little sad face.

I'm not ready to 100% wean yet, but would like to eliminate the overnight nursings, and keep daytime to morning, naptime and bedtime.

a little background, we co-sleep both our kids, we have no place for my daughter to sleep, so moving her to another bed is not an option, we don't have another bed and don't have a space for one even if we did, as our house is very small, and we are to broke to buy anything.

My husband works A LOT, so I cannot have him get up with her overnight when she wakes isn't an option either.

I could use ideas on how to get her to graze less during the day and how to eliminate overnight, I can pick her up and rock her and rub her back, but she was up 5x last night, I nursed her 1x, then held her, then put her down when asleep, then nursed her again, for like 5 min then held her again, then nursed her about 3x (since it was after 5 am, I considered that morning)

also, I do give her a snack at bedtime, doesn't seem to help.

thanks so much.

2 moms found this helpful

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

So What Happened?

Well it is still an ongoing battle, but last night for the first time from 10 pm until 6:30 am, she didn't nurse. Course my daughter woke up 3x asking for it, but I didn't give in. I just held her in my arms and fell asleep with her in my arms, and she eventually gave up and fell to sleep. I just hope over time, sooner rather than later, she stops waking to ask for the boob and just sleeps all night. :-)

thanks so much to everyone for their great suggestions. They definitely are the reason why I put my foot down and made her stop eating through the night, now I just have to hope it gets easier faster.

thanks again!

D.

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

P.N.

answers from Boston on

I nightweaned DD at 28 months. We coslept as well. She was still waking a couple times a night. It took 4 nights for her but I figured she was ready as she had stopped nursing to sleep exclusively. During the day I explained that we weren't nursing at night anymore but that I would help her get back to sleep if she awoke. No milk until the sun was up I explained. I offered water and hugs. She was mad and cried, but this lessened each night until the 5th night she no longer awoke (though I still did!).

My husband wasn't really involved. He was there and awoken, but I did it mostly. We continued to cosleep as well, it was not an issue for DD.

You may find that if you night wean she will have more needs for nursing during the day initially, she may need the connection more. So I probably wouldn't tackle both at once. But probably a week or 2 after night weaning you can work on the grazing.

With DD I made sure she always had a cup of water around and I made sure that she had meals and snacks periodically so hunger or thirst would not be an issue.

I also used distraction when I felt it was boredom nursing or something. If she would ask soon after nursing I would offer her a snack or put her off a bit and offer a project or activity. This often worked. If she really needed it, that became apparent, but if it was boredom or just something to do, she would happily move on.

You need to be matter of fact and NOT feel guilty about it. "Oh let's do that in a few minutes, come here and look at this!" If you get frustrated with her or get into a battle of wills over it, it will make it that much more important for her. Just don't make it something to feel sad about. Say Yes, but then distract. If her thirst and hunger are already satisfied and if she is feeling that she is getting enough attention from you then she should go along. I know often if DD was constantly asking to nurse I realized that I was trying to do my own thing too much and she just really wanted some attention.

It is best to eliminate one nursing at a time, with at least 3-4 days before eliminating another one. (That's witht he daytime stuff, I think at night at this age it is easiest to just have none at all, otherwise it's too confusing) Also, recognize that nursing is about connection too so she may need more attention from you. You should try to substitute other attachment activities instead. If you try to just keep busy to avoid it, it may backfire and make her really want to hang onto all those nursings that much more.

"Mothering Your Nursing Toddler" is a book that may be helpful. She has a chapter in there on weaning. Your library may have it or get in touch with your local LaLeche League group. They may have a lending library and I'm sure they've got a copy.

And just remember to have patience. She's been doing it this way for almost 2 years, so you can't expect to change things overnight.

2 moms found this helpful

M.L.

answers from Hartford on

I am in the same boat with my son, it is hard. It is not because she is hungry, she just wants you. I used to give mine a bottle of water instead. Then you have the same problem with that or try a cup of water. It is hard, besides letting them scream!

M. - SAHM and WAHM and love it!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.C.

answers from Boston on

I have had the same issues with each of my children. Each co-slept. We were able to night wean using Elizabeth Pantley's Pop off method. I highly recommend it. It works in a matter of days. We also did that for nap and fianlly bed time weaning as well.. Good luck!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

N.D.

answers from Springfield on

My son weaned from a binky by being explained that he was too big for it now--I know not at all the same thing but if you could explain to her that night time is sleep time for everyone--especially mommy maybe she could get that idea. Here is your last boobie for the night (before sleep) and then hold to that--it will suck for a few days but if you wear a tighter shirt with no access...... Sorry, that's all I have for you. Hope it works out no matter what. I get the whole working real hard and still broke thing. Best of luck to you, Nat

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.M.

answers from Boston on

Although I can't be of too much help out of personal experience, I can pass along what a friend of mine had to do. They, too, co-slept with their 2-yr-old son, and he would wake up several times a night to nurse. Finally, though, enough was enough when she was pregnant and exhausted, so for awhile, she slept on the couch with earplugs and the dad would stay in the bed and comfort their son back to sleep. It only took a few nights before he was sleeping through the night fine.

As far as another bed goes... when I was in 4th grade, my family of 5 lived in a teeny tiny summer camp. I know all about being broke. My mom managed to squeeze a toddler bed in the washer/dryer nook for my little sister, and it worked. (Now that I think back I wonder when or how my mom did laundry...?) So if you do get a little creative and find a place you might be able to fit a little bed, people are give away toddler beds all the time on Craigslist or Freecycle. I strongly suggest looking at those sites regularly, anyway, even if you don't want a bed, because you might find other great and useful things on there. I have received all kinds of kids' items through those, and have also decluttered by giving other stuff away myself.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions