J.S.
best advice i ever got was to allow him to use the pull up but **he had to use the bathroom like everyone else**. no more hiding in the corner. eventually, i said enough is enough and when i knew he was going to do his thing i put him on the pot and he did it there, had a major happy dance and he got to go to the toy store and get anything he wanted (a firetruck). Had one accident and has never looked back. stressful on the parent though. ds#2, he was stubborn as hell and i had to use a timer for all toileting. i set the timer for every 15 minutes and he HAD to use the toilet when it rang, no matter what. quickly he learned i meant business and cut the funny business. pooping was another story, he'd hold it for days. then it was painful to poop and he got really clingy and crabby. sooo... he got to pick out a small toy (one for pee and one for poop) and i hung them over the toilet. when he went in the toilet, he got the prize 9had to stay dry all day for the pee prize and poop in the toilet for the poop prize). he still held the pooping for days, in fear of the pain. try reasoning with a 3yo!! ugh. i would tell him the more you go the easier it is and fed him things that would help things move along. finally i busted out suppositories. that took about two tries and then all i had to do was threaten to get the suppositories and he'd poop!! every kid is different. good luck. btw, he potty trained fully in about two weeks. now for advice on cleanig yourself? that is what we need here.