Sounds to me that learning when and how set boundaries and provide consequences wold be a help. I'm guessing you've had difficulties consistently setting boundaries and giving consequences for your daughtER sonce she was 13 or so. Your daughter does not believe you'll throw her out. You allowed her to come back home. You've given her second, third and fourth chances. You just get mad/frustrated because she doesn't follow the rules and you continue to let her stay. Sounds like you told her the rules and didn't check to see.if she understood she had to take responsibility. Did you see or hear anything before bringing her back home that indicated she had changed?
I urge you to get professional counseling. You absolutely can not change her! Counseling will help you learn about boundaries and consequences. It can help you know when to stand your ground and when to let her learn the hard way.
Why did you order her off the roof? The natural consequence was for a neighbor to complain directly to her. The way that you describe your interactions with your daughter, suggests to me that the two of you lack having effective ways to talk and reach an agreement. Telling most people, but especially a teen exactly what they have to do, usually backfires. To have an effective conversation both people need to feel heard. I suspect that all her life, you've been her boss even tho she needed to learn how to make decisions that would result in her being a responsible adult.
I suggest that it's too late for you to change your relationship with her. Both of you missed opportunities to grow together. When she's older and more mature you can try to be "friends." Perhaps you give in because you feel responsible for how she acts. I suggest that you continue to give her one more chance.hoping that she will act differently this time. You cannot change the way she feels and acts.
You are not responsible for her actions. You are responsible for your actions. Obviously letting her live with you is not working. I believe, at this point, your daughter will have to learn how to be a successful adult, through her own experience. She has to feel pain before she'll.know she has to do things differently.
I suggest that instead of just kicking her out tomorrow,.set some boundaries. Tell her that this isn't working and give her a deadline for when she has to be out. Don't try to get her to follow the rules. Don't argue with her. Don't talk about rules at all. When she asks to stay, repeat the move out by date. Ask her if she'd like your help to find another place. Only help if she asks you to help.
You do need support to do this. You need a professional counselor to back you up. Gather strength from that person. You will feel guilty. A counselor will help you deal with your feelings.
She is an adult. It's her responsibility to figure out her life. It's your responsibility to figure out your life. Get guidance in how to do free yourself.
If you'll feel better, find resources for her. Tell her you have ideas and phone numbers but give them to her only if she wants them. You cannot control her! So stop trying to do so.
My daughter and her boyfriend lived with me when they were 19 so they could work and my daughter go to school. They got pregnant. The boyfriend had difficulty being responsible at work. My daughter was working. I asked them to find their own place because they were taking on the added responsibility of a baby. My daughter did ask for help finding an apartment, getting financial aide and medical insurance. Asking her to leave was difficult. I had difficulty with boundaries and consequences when she was a teen. She is now married and self sufficient. I learned, with difficulty, to transition from being a parent to being a friend. Wit the help of counseling for both of us, we are now good friends.
You fell into the trap again. What makes you think she will ever get her GED or save money???? What makes you think counseling will work this time? It hasn't helped the last umpteenth times?