A.D.
If I remember from when I was in the Brownies (Yikes...TOO many years ago!) it was peeled grapes in water for eyeballs, spaghetti with a little oil for intestines, cauliflower with olive oil for brains, peanut shells for "toenails", but I guess anything peanut is out these days...a flat piece of chicken or something for a tongue, rice was "maggots" (maybe too much for kindergarteners!), jello was just deemed "Guts" and maybe some "gummy worms" wet would make good worms?
I remember we did it where we had to put our hands into a hole in a box to feel these things. (And on the last one, someone on the other side grabbed your hand....but I wouldn't recommend that with the young kids!)