Sarah, what is it that your brother is passionate about? The gift should play to his desires and hobbies. For example, my mother is a hard worker and LOVES a little pampering. But she would never pay for herself to get a massage or a pedicure. So that was her gift from us girls on Mother's Day. My Dad is an old military man who loves to play golf, go out shooting on the range, and tinker with music equipment. We bought him a record player that transfers old vinyls to mp3's. My husband is a music junkie. If I can find a great pair of strings for his guitar or a great new cd, he is very happy.
FOr your brother, does he like to have that extra something- like a really great men's cologne, "man jewelry", a new leather wallet, music, books, movies, a plaque with something personal or poetic engraved on it, etc- or a guys night out (movies or golfing or game night)- play to the things that he loves but does not indulge in for himself. I know you want to stay away from the generic gift card, but you can do specific ones- like $xx.00 towards a new suit, etc. I am not a great gift giver, but my husband is, and I am learning from him. Down to the wrapping paper, if you are excited about your gift, then he will love it that much more. The fact is, it is something from your heart to his. THe biggest thing is for him to know how proud everyone is of his accomplishments and to not bash the things that did not pan out. Life is about trial and error and spending quality time on the things you love while working to support that. Happiness is of the utmost. Make your joy for him a top priority- it will be contagious!