HI B.,
You got a lot of good responses. I am certanly no expert. I am actually right with you. My baby girl will be 7 months this week and we're still struggling with what works best.
I couldn't do the "letting her cry" routine. I have been critizesed by some family members cos they say I will pay my dues later but my daughter is extremely sensitive and if I let her cry too much she gets so upset. Bedtime was becoming so dreadful for all of us, her, my and daddy. I was beggining to feel almost scared of what would happen at night and she sensed it, she became aggitated and would fight off sleep more.
I gave up on forcing her, she'll have the rest of her life to learn to put herself to sleep. My mom (based on her mother's advice) let me cry it out when I was ONE MONTH OLD! I know they were different times but I had a really hard time trusting her as a child, I had separation anxiety so bad that I would panic in stores and look for a trustworthy face everwhere I went. It was extreme, I would be teased by my sibblings, they would hide just to see my petrifies face.
My point... All children are diff and approaches could harm a child. I understand my behavior NOW, didn't know why then.
I don't let her nap after 5. I feed her nightly at 630, bathe her at 8pm. bottle at 8:30 while rocking her. We're both more relaxed now so even if she's not "out" she doesn't cry when I lay her down. She does wake up through the night and I go in, touch her head, rub her back, give her the paci and she goes back to sleep. Sometimes she awakens more times than others. Sometimes I wait to see if she cries, if she just whines and moves around I do not go in.
That's all I can do, we'll see what happens. I woudl let her sleep with me but she'd wake up with noise and we stay up longer than her. We also need our privacy so I prefer not to. She's been in her room since she was 3 months cos we woke up her constantly if we sneezed, coughed etc.
Let me know how it goes!
Amy