L.W.
I've taken it away from both my sons the same way, first at 9 months, second at 1 year. I cut the tips off. My first son was doing what you're going through. It was driving me crazy. As if he was 2 months again, waking up all the time, but just for pacifier. He would suck on it for a couple of minutes, get frustrated and put it out. It took two nights. The third night, he spit it out, and literally threw it, and never looked back. It was as if he made the decision. My second son did take a little longer, I think because of the age, but still only about 3-4 nights before he quite completely, and once again, like it was his decision. I know it sounds crazy, but i think even at that age, they like to feel in control of SOMETHING! Good luck, and do it now! I think the earlier the better.