Eye Concealer

I really love the eye brightener pencil from Origins. I had looked for awhile for something, and this was the best find!

I use a concealer by Chantecaille, sold at Nordstrom (Mall of America). It is called a bio lift concealer and actually makes under-eye circles less puffy, too. It is a bit pricey, but you could stop in and see a consultant for a free trial/help with color selection.

I use Physicians Formula Conceal RX with a sponge makeup applicator. I then use my regular cream foundation and set with a light powder. I have very sensitive skin, so I only buy the Physicians Formula products. They can be found at any drugstore.

There's a little "wand" type thing that's made by Pixie (?) that comes in a light green (mint colored) container. It's sold at Target...and I swear by it. You sweep it under your eyes and it really lightens up the area.

Lancome Protective Undereye Concealer

I've used MAC concealer for years. It's the creamy stuff in the pot, not the liquid stuff. I've got super dark circles and very pale skin and this is the only thing that has worked for me and doesn't look off on my skin tone. I get it at Macy's at Mayfair Mall (I see you're in Oak Creek, so not too far). Not sure if it's sold elsewhere in the area. Good luck!

I use the SmartShade concealer from Almay. I get it at CVS.
It's nice because it matches your skin color, so you don't look like a racoon. (or reverse racoon!) LOL!