I was just at a junction where I needed to change carriers. I was interested in having a smartphone but refused to pay the extra for the data plan. Then I found what ridiculous amount all of the companies wanted for JUST talk and text.
In the end we ended up trying out Straighttalk. They are a prepaid plan that is only sold at Walmart or online. Straighttalk operates off of either the Verizon, Sprint, T-Mobile, or AT&T network. I was told that it was dependent upon which company supported your particular phone. I wanted to switch to the AT&T network so I asked customer service to give me a list of phones supported by them and then purchased one of their phones.
There is a wide range of phones and price points to choose from. Dependent on the carrier there are very few dumbphones. The good news is that unlimited talk, text, and data is $45 a month. You pay an additional $1 EMS (911) fee but otherwise there are no fees and taxes. (If you can find a dumbphone that service is only $30 a month.)
I was very skeptical and worried about trying Straighttalk but figured I had nothing to lose since it is a month to month plan. I completed my "trial" month at the end of December and renewed my service for January.
My only issue was when I loaded a new phone card for January it did not register (It worked fine on my husband's.) but I did not realize it until my phone deactivated. I called customer service and they got it taken care of no questions asked.
Now that I am growing more confident in my decision, I will more than likely do an auto-refill where they automatically charge me and refill after my 30 days expires each month. That way I will never have to worry about buying cards to reload it.
I was very skeptical before making the leap, but I heard all good things and can say that my experience has been good as well.