J.H.
I think I got my girls' done at Icing in Quail, and they were pretty good. The problem with those places is that it just depends on who's working there, but the equipment & size of earrings have come a long way in recent years too. You could try a reputable tattoo/piercing shop instead - 23rd Street Piercing is a little out of your way, but they're good peeps :]